256 THE SEVEN BOOKS OF [Doox v.
not you? Who that pretty boys, and even grown-up [men]
of very fine appearance, were wrongfully lusted after? [was
it] not you? Who [declared that they! were] mutilated,
debauched,’ skilled in dissimulation, thieves, held in bonds
and chains, finally assailed with thunderbolts, [and] wounded,
that they died, [and] even found graves on earth? [was it]
not you? While, then, so many and grievous charges have
been raised by you to the injury of the gods, do you dare to
assert that the gods have been displeased because of us, while
it has long been clear that you are the guilty causes of such
anger, and the occasion of the divine wrath ?
32. But you err, says [my opponent], and are mistaken,
and show, even in criticising [these] things, that you are
rather ignorant, unlearned, and boorish. For all those
stories which seem to you disgraceful, and tending to the
discredit of the gods, contain in them holy mysteries, theories
wonderful and profound, and not such as any one can easily
become acquainted with by force of understanding. For
that is not meant and said which has been written and placed
on the surface of the story; but all these things are under-
stood in allegorical senses, and by means of secret explana-
tions privately supplied? Therefore he who says* Jupiter lay
with his mother, does not mean the incestuous or shameful
embraces of Venus, but names Jupiter instead of rain, and
Ceres instead of the earth. And he, again, who says that
he? dealt lasciviously with his daughter, speaks of no filthy
pleasures, but puts Jupiter for the name of a shower, and by
his daughter means? the crop sown. So, too, he who says
that Proserpina was carried off by father Dis, does not
say (as you suppose‘) that the maiden was carried off to
[gratify] the basest desires; but because we cover the seed
with clods, he signifies that the goddess has sunk under the
1 j,e, the gods. 2 Exoletos. Cf. iv. c. 35, n. 8.
3 Subditivis secretis.
* Both Roman edd. and Ms. read dicet—''shall say ;” all others as
above—dicit.
5 i.e. Jupiter. 6 Lit., ‘in the signification of his daughter.”
7 So the margin of Ursinus—uwt reris for the MS. ut ce-reris.