But he has reached the irrefutable argument which we long ago detected lurking in the
sequel of his statements1049, but which is here proclaimed aloud without disguise. For he
wishes to show that the essence of the Son is subject to passion, and to decay, and in no wise
differs from material nature, which is in a state of flux, that by this means he may demonstrate
His difference from the Father. For he says, “If he can show that the God Who is over all,
Who is the Light unapproachable, was incarnate or could be incarnate, came under authority,
obeyed commands, came under the laws of men, bore the Cross, let him say that the Light
is equal to the Light.” If these words had been brought forward by us as following by necessary
consequence from premises laid down by Eunomius, who would not have charged us with
unfairness, in employing an over-subtle dialectic to reduce our adversaries’ statement to
such an absurdity? But as things stand, the fact that they themselves make no attempt to
suppress the absurdity that naturally follows from their assumption, helps to support our
contention that it was not without due reflection that, with the help of truth, we censured
the argument of heresy. For behold, how undisguised and outspoken is their striving against
the Only-begotten God! Nay, by His enemies His work of mercy is reckoned a means of
disparaging and maligning the Nature of the Son of God, as though not of deliberate purpose,
but by a compulsion of His Nature he had slipped down to life in the flesh, and to the suf-
fering of the Cross! And as it is the nature of a stone to fall downward, and of fire to rise
upward, and as these material objects do not exchange their natures one with another, so
that the stone should have an upward tendency, and fire be depressed by its weight and sink
downwards, even so they make out that passion was part of the very Nature of the Son, and
that for this cause He came to that which was akin and familiar to Him, but that the Nature
of the Father, being free from such passions, remained unapproachable by the contact of
evil. For he says, that the God Who is over all, Who is Light unapproachable, neither was
incarnate nor could be incarnate. The first of the two statements was quite enough, that the
Father did not become incarnate. But now by his addition a double absurdity arises; for he
either charges the Son with evil, or the Father with powerlessness. For if to partake of our
flesh is evil, then he predicates evil of the Only-begotten God; but if the lovingkindness to
man was good, then he makes out the Father to be powerless for good, by saying that it
245
would not have been in His power to have effectually bestowed such grace by taking flesh.
And yet who in the world does not know that life-giving power proceeds to actual operation
both in the Father and in the Son? “For as the Father raiseth up the dead and quickeneth
them,” He says, “even so the Son quickeneth whom He will1050,”—meaning obviously by
“dead” us who had fallen from the true life. If then it is even so as the Father quickeneth,
and not otherwise, that the Son brings to operation the same grace, how comes it that the
1049 The passage has already been cited by S. Gregory, Book V §3 (p. 176 sup.).
1050 S. John v. 21
467
He further proceeds notably to interpret the language of the Gospel, “In…