Since, however, Eunomius asserts that the word “Lord” is used
in reference to the essence and not to the dignity of the
Only-begotten, and cites as a witness to this view the Apostle, when he
says to the Corinthians, “Now the Lord is the Spirit 2 Cor. iii.
17.,” it may perhaps be opportune that we
should not pass over even this error on his part without correction. He
asserts that the word “Lord” is significative of essence,
and by way of proof of this assumption he brings up the passage above
mentioned. “The Lord,” it says, “is the Spirit 2 Cor. iii.
17..” But our friend who interprets
Scripture at his own sweet will calls “Lordship” by the
name of “essence,” and thinks to bring his statement
to proof by means of the words quoted. Well, if it had been said by
Paul, “Now the Lord is essence,” we too would have
concurred in his argument. But seeing that the inspired writing on the
one side says, “the Lord is the Spirit,” and Eunomius says
on the other, “Lordship is essence,” I do not know where he
finds support for his statement, unless he is prepared to say again It is
not quite clear whether πάλιν is to be
constructed with λέγοι or
with κεῖσθαι, but the difference in sense is slight. that the word “Spirit” stands in
Scripture for “essence.” Let us consider, then, whether the
Apostle anywhere, in his use of the term “Spirit,” employs
that word to indicate “essence.” He says, “The Spirit
itself beareth witness with our Spirit Rom. viii. 16.,” and “no one knoweth the things
of a man save the Spirit of man which is in him 1 Cor. ii. 11.,” and “the letter killeth, but
the Spirit giveth life 2 Cor. iii. 6.,” and “if
ye through the Spirit do mortify the deeds of the body, ye shall live Rom. viii. 13.,” and “if we live in the Spirit
let us also walk in the Spirit Gal. v. 25..” Who indeed
could count the utterances of the Apostle on this point? and in them we
nowhere find “essence” signified by this word. For he who
says that “the Spirit itself beareth witness with our
spirit,” signifies nothing else than the Holy Spirit Which comes
to be in the mind of the faithful; for in many other passages of his
writings he gives the name of spirit to the mind, on the reception by
which of the communion of the Spirit the recipients attain the dignity
of adoption. Again, in the passage, “No one knoweth the things of
a man save the spirit of man which is in him,” if
“man” is used of the essence, and “spirit”
likewise, it will follow from the phrase that the man is maintained to
be of two essences. Again, I know not how he who says that “the
letter killeth, but the Spirit giveth life,” sets
“essence” in opposition to “letter”; nor,
again, how this writer imagines that when Paul says that we ought
“through the Spirit” to destroy “the deeds of the
body,” he is directing the signification of “spirit”
to express “essence”; while as for “living in the
Spirit,” and “walking in the Spirit,” this would be
quite unintelligible if the sense of the word “Spirit”
referred to “essence.” For in what else than in essence do
all we who are alive partake of life?—thus when the Apostle is
laying down advice for us on this matter that we should “live in
essence,” it is as though he said “partake of life by means
of yourselves, and not by means of others.” If then it is not
possible that this sense can be adopted in any passage, how can
Eunomius here once more imitate the interpreters of dreams, and bid us
to take “spirit” for “essence,” to the end that
he may arrive in due syllogistic form at his conclusion that the word
“Lord” is applied to the essence?—for if
“spirit” is “essence” (he argues), and
“the Lord is Spirit,” the “Lord” is clearly
found to be “essence.” How incontestable is the force of
this attempt! How can we evade or resolve this irrefragable necessity
of demonstration? The word “Lord,” he says, is spoken of
the essence. How does he maintain it? Because the Apostle says,
“The Lord is the Spirit.” Well, what has this to do with essence? He
gives us the further instruction that “spirit” is put for
“essence.” These are the arts of his demonstrative method!
These are the results of his Aristotelian science! This is why, in your
view, we are so much to be pitied, who are uninitiated in this wisdom!
and you of course are to be deemed happy, who track out the truth by a
method like this—that the Apostle’s meaning was such that
we are to suppose “the Spirit” was put by him for the
Essence of the Only-begotten!