These facts not only confirm the tradition which places him at Nineveh, but they go far to account for the obscurity in
which his name and his writings lay so long. In an age of excited
controversy, these quiet hortatory discourses, marked by no striking
eloquence of style or subtlety of reasoning, dealing with no burning
question of the time, nor with any disputes more recent than those of
the two previous centuries, or those between Jew and Christian, would
hardly attain to more than a local circulation; and when they
penetrated to Edessa or other such centres of Syriac theological life,
would awaken but a languid interest. That they did so penetrate
is certain; for of the existing mss. whence we
derive their text, one (the oldest) was written in Edessa in 474, and
Isaac of Antioch, who knew and imitated them, before that time, was a
disciple of Zenobius of Edessa. But the paucity of such
mss., and still more the oblivion which so
long covered the name of Aphrahat, prove, either, that the work failed
to attain popularity—or, that it provoked some prejudice which
led to its practical suppression. It would be difficult, however,
to point out anything in it to which exception could be so seriously
taken as to be a bar to its acceptance. None of the errors which
so keen a critic as Georgius detected in its theology—even if we
admit the justice of his censure—is such as to shock the
orthodoxy of the fourth or fifth century.