PHILOSOPHY
with Ferrier, and I regard his analysis as much more satis-
factory than that of many later writers. But his treatment is
none the less defective ; and the deficiency is just such as might
have been remedied by a closer and more docile study of the
philosophers whom he is ostensibly explaining—Plato and
Socrates as represented by Plato. Ferrier goes astray in the
same way as Kant in identifying the universal with the
merely general. For him a concept is always merely a discour-
sive class-concept ; the unity which is thought in it is merely
that of the common nature of a class as separately exempli-
fied in each of its individual members. Thus the relation
of the particular to the universal is regarded by him as
merely consisting in the relation of a particular instance or
case to that of which it is a particular instance or case ; as,
for example, this or that member of the class, men, is a
particular case or instance in which human nature is exemplified.
Had he considered carefully what is involved in such a universal
as Plato's Idea of the Good, he would probably have been led to
see the essential inadequacy of this position. For the Idea of the
Good can never be exemplified within the limits of any particular
instance, and the same holds for all ideals as such. None the
less, Ferrier's discussion really supplies a useful introduction to
Plato. He fails, indeed, to bring out the most distinctive features
of the Platonic doctrine. But the further exposition ofthe theory
of ideas could not proceed better, for the beginner, than by
showing how and why he fails, by showing how much more
there is in Plato than in Ferrier's account of him.
All Ferrier's other work shows the same characteristic
features as the Lectures on Greek Philosophy. We must not
expect from him accurate and patient unravelling of the com-
plexities of special problems, or careful and exhaustive analysis of
possible alternatives. He had no faculty for detail, not even for
the detailed development of his own views. His strength lies in
157