deserted their tribunal after having compeared before it, but had always declined compear-
ance because of the suspicions which they entertained.
8. This consideration ought to have weighed much with Secundus, who was at that time
Primate, if his desire, as president of the Council, was to promote peace; for he might perhaps
have quieted or restrained the mouths of those who were raging against men who were absent,
if he had spoken thus: “Ye see, brethren, how after so great havoc of persecution peace has
been given to us, through God’s mercy, by the princes of this world; surely we, being
Christians and bishops, ought not to break up the Christian unity which even pagan enemies
have ceased to assail. Either, therefore, let us leave to God, as Judge, all those cases which
the calamity of a most troublous time has brought upon the Church; or if there be some
among you who have such certain knowledge of the guilt of other parties, that they are able
to bring against them a definite indictment, and prove it if they plead not guilty, and who
also shrink from having communion with such persons, let them hasten to our brethren
and peers, the bishops of the churches beyond the sea, and present to them in the first place
a complaint concerning the conduct and contumacy of the accused, as having through
consciousness of guilt declined the jurisdiction of their peers in Africa, so that by these foreign
bishops they may be summoned to compear and answer before them regarding the things
laid to their charge. If they disobey this summons, their criminality and obduracy will become
known to those other bishops; and by a synodical letter sent in their name to all parts of the
world throughout which the Church of Christ is now extended, the parties accused will be
excluded from communion with all churches, in order to prevent the springing up of error
in the see of the Church at Carthage. When that has been done, and these men have been
separated from the whole Church, we shall without fear ordain another bishop over the
community in Carthage; whereas, if now another bishop be ordained by us, communion
will most probably be withheld from him by the Church beyond the sea, because they will
not recognise the validity of the deposition of the bishop, whose ordination was everywhere
acknowledged, and with whom letters of communion had been exchanged; and thus, through
our undue eagerness to pronounce without deliberation a final sentence, the great scandal
of schism within the Church, when it has rest from without, may arise, and we may be found
presuming to set up another altar, not against Cæcilianus, but against the universal Church,
which, uninformed of our procedure, would still hold communion with him.”
9. If any one had been disposed to reject sound and equitable counsels such as these,
what could he have done? or how could he have procured the condemnation of any one of
his absent peers, when he could not have any decisions with the authority of the Council,
seeing that the Primate was opposed to him? And if such a serious revolt against the authority
634
To Glorius, Eleusius, etc.