contrary ways, as he pleases; or rather he suffers as men do who are deprived of sight; for
they too behave often in unseemly ways before the eyes of those who see, supposing, because
they themselves cannot see, that they are also unseen. For what sort of man is it who does
not see the contradiction in his words? Because it is “generated,” he says, the essence leaves
other things no room for community, for it is only-begotten; and then when he has uttered
these words, really as though he did not see or did not suppose himself to be seen, he tacks
on, as if corresponding to what he has said, things that have nothing in common with them,
coupling “the operation of the maker” with the essence of the Only-begotten. That which
is generated is correlative to the generator, and the Only-begotten, surely, by consequence,
to the Father; and he who looks to the truth beholds, in co-ordination with the Son, not “the
operation of the maker,” but the nature of Him that begat Him. But he, as if he were talking
about plants or seeds, or some other thing in the order of creation, sets “the operation of
the maker” by the side of the existence662 of the Only-begotten. Why, if a stone or a stick,
or something of that sort, were the subject of consideration, it would be logical to pre-suppose
“the operation of the maker”; but if the Only-begotten God is confessed, even by His ad-
versaries, to be a Son, and to exist by way of generation, how do the same words befit Him
that befit the lowest portions of the creation? how do they think it pious to say concerning
the Lord the very thing which may be truly said of an ant or a gnat? For if any one understood
the nature of an ant, and its peculiar ties in reference to other living things, he would not
be beyond the truth in saying that “the operation of its maker is not contemplated as com-
mon” with reference to the other things. What, therefore, is affirmed of such things as these,
this they predicate also of the Only-begotten, and as hunters are said to intercept the passage
of their game with holes, and to conceal their design by covering over the mouths of the
holes with some unsound and unsubstantial material, in order that the pit may seem level
with the ground about it, so heresy contrives against men something of the same sort, cov-
ering over the hole of their impiety with these fine-sounding and pious names, as it were
with a level thatch, so that those who are rather unintelligent, thinking that these men’s
preaching is the same with the true faith, because of the agreement of their words, hasten
towards the mere name of the Son and the Only-begotten, and step into emptiness in the
hole, since the significance of these titles will not sustain the weight of their tread, but lets
them down into the pitfall of the denial of Christ. This is why he speaks of the generated
essence that leaves nothing room for community, and calls it “Only-begotten.” These are
the coverings of the hole. But when any one stops before he is caught in the gulf, and puts
forth the test of argument, like a hand, upon his discourse, he sees the dangerous downfall
of idolatry lying beneath the doctrine. For when he draws near, as though to God and the
Son of God, he finds a creature of God set forth for his worship. This is why they proclaim
662 ὑποστάσε.
320
He then clearly and skilfully criticises the doctrine of the impossibility…