Upon the so-called bishops of Jerusalem down to the destruction of
the city under Hadrian, see Bk. IV. chap. 5. Upon the destruction of
Jerusalem under Hadrian, and the founding of the Gentile Church in
Ælia Capitolina, and upon Marcus the first Gentile bishop, see Bk.
IV. chap. 6.
The list given here by
Eusebius purports to contain fifteen names, Marcus being the sixteenth,
and Narcissus being the thirtieth; but only thirteen names are given.
In the Chron., however, and in Epiphanius (Hær.
LXVI. 20) the list is complete, a second Maximus and a Valentinus being
inserted, as 26th and 27th, between Capito and Valens. The omission
here is undoubtedly due simply to the mistake of some scribe. The
Chron. puts the accession of Cassianus into the 23d year of
Antoninus Pius (160 a.d.), and the accession
of the second Maximus into the sixth year of Commodus (185 a.d.), but it is said in the Chron. itself that the
dates of the various bishops are not known, and hence no reliance can
be placed upon these figures. Epiphanius puts the accession of the
first Gaius into the tenth year of Antoninus Pius, which is thirteen
years earlier than the date of the Chron. for the fourth bishop
preceding. He also puts the death of the second Gaius in the eighth
year of Marcus Aurelius (168 a.d.) and the
death of the second Maximus in the sixteenth year of the same reign,
thus showing a variation from the Chron. of more than nine
years. The episcopate of Dolichianus is brought down by him to the
reign of Commodus (180 a.d.). As shown in note
1, however, the date given by him for Narcissus is quite wrong, and
there is no reason for bestowing any greater credence upon his other
dates. Syncellus assigns five years to Cassianus, five to Publius, four
to Maximus, two to Julian, three to the first Gaius, two to Symmachus,
three to the second Gaius, four to the second Julian, two to an Elias
who is not named by our other authorities, four to Capito, four to the
second Maximus, five to Antoninus, three to Valens, four to Narcissus
the first time, and ten the second time. His list, however, is
considerably confused,—Dolichianus being thrown after Narcissus
with an episcopate of twelve years,—and at any rate no reliance
can be placed upon the figures given. We must conclude that we have no
means of ascertaining the dates of these various bishops until we reach
Narcissus. We know nothing about any of them (Narcissus excepted)
beyond the fact that they were bishops.