This
shows the bitterness of the hostility of the Catholics toward the
Montanists. That even when suffering together for the one Lord they
could not recognize these brethren seems very sad, and it is not to be
wondered at that the Montanists felt themselves badly used, and looked
upon the Catholics as “slayers of the prophets,” &c.
More uncompromising enmity than this we can hardly imagine. That the
Catholics, however, were sincere in their treatment of the Montanists,
we cannot doubt. It is clear that they firmly believed that association
with them meant association with the devil, and hence the deeper their
devotion to Christ, the deeper must be their abhorrence of these
instruments of Satan. Compare, for instance, Polycarp’s words to
Marcion, quoted in Bk. IV. chap. 14, above. The attitude of these
Catholic martyrs is but of a piece with that of nearly all the orthodox
Fathers toward heresy. It only shows itself here in its extremest
form.