all things, from eternity to eternity, in one, most perfect, and unalterable view; so that his
whole eternal duration is vitae interminabilis, tota, simul et perfecta possessio.
On the whole, I need not fear to say, that there is no geometrical theorem or proposition
whatsoever, more capable of strict demonstration, than that God’s certain Prescience of the
volitions of moral agents is inconsistent with such a Contingence of these events, as is
without all Necessity; and so is inconsistent with the Arminian notion of liberty.
Corol. 2. Hence the doctrine of the Calvinists, concerning the absolute decrees of God,
does not all infer any more fatality in things, than will demonstrably follow from the doctrine
of the most Arminiandivines, who acknowledge God’s omniscience, and universal Prescience.
Therefore all objections they make against the doctrine of the Calvinists, as implying Hobbes’s
doctrine of Necessity, or the stoical doctrine of fate, lie no more against the doctrine of
Calvinists, than their own doctrine: and therefore it doth not become those divines, to raise
such an outcry against the Calvinists, on this account.
Corol. 3. Hence all arguments of Arminians, who own God’s omniscience, against the
doctrine of the inability of unregenerate men to perform the conditions of salvation, and
the commands of God requiring spiritual duties, and against the Calvinistic doctrine of ef-
ficacious grace; on this ground, that those doctrines, though they do not suppose men to
be under any constraint or coaction, yet suppose them under Necessity, must fall to the
ground. And their arguments against the Necessity of men’s volitions, taken from the reas-
onableness of God’s commands, promises, and threatenings, and the sincerity of his counsels
and invitations; and all objections against any doctrines of the Calvinistsas being inconsistent
with human liberty, because they infer Necessity; I say, all these arguments and objections
must be justly esteemed vain and frivolous, as coming from them; being leveled against their
40
own doctrine, as well as against that of the Calvinists. 124
124 In these two sections our author has abundantly demonstrated, that foreknowledge infers necessity; such
a necessity as exists in the connexion of a consequent with its antecedent; and has represented, in various lights,
how the most contradictory and absurd conclusions follow from the opposite hypothesis. But as his argument,
strictly speaking, did not require a further explanation or distinction of the principles on which it rested, which
yet are important, it may not be improper in this place briefly to inquire into the rationale of those principles;
by which his reasoning may appear with additional evidence, and the radical principles themselves confirmed
by their connexion with others. As these remarks are presented in the form of a series analytically disposed, we
shall prefix to them the corresponding ordinal numbers. 1. Any kind of necessity is a sufficient ground of fore-
knowledge, in the view of omniscience; but as is the kind of necessity, or the nature of the connexion between
cause and effect, so is the nature of the foreknowledge. But this difference in the nature of the connexion af-
fects—not the certainty of the event, but the mode of causation; or from what cause the certainty arises. 2. All
617
SECTION XII. God's certain Foreknowledge of the future volitions of moral…