A
careful exegesis of the passages in John’s Gospel, which are
supposed by some to contradict the synoptic account, and to put
Christ’s death on the fourteenth day of Nisan instead of on the
fifteenth, shows that John agrees with the Synoptists in putting the
passover meal on the fourteenth and the death of Christ on the
fifteenth (see Schaff’s Ch. Hist. Vol. I. p. 133 ff., and
the authorities referred to by him). The Asiatic churches, in observing
the fourteenth of Nisan, were commemorating the last passover feast and
the death of the paschal Lamb. Their practice did not imply that they
believed that Christ died on the fourteenth (as can be seen from
fragments of Apolinarius’ work quoted in the Chron.
Paschale, and referred to above; see, also, Schaff, Vol. II. p.
214). They were in full agreement with all four Gospels in putting his
death on the fifteenth. But the paschal controversy did not hinge on
the day of the month on which Christ died,—in regard to which
there was no widespread disagreement,—but on the question as to
whether a particular day of the week or of the month was to be
celebrated.