From p. 57 to the end of his second section, p. 75, he
giveth us a scheme of religion, which, in his scoffing language, he says,
“men learn from an acquaintance with the person of Christ; and affirms, “that there needs no more to expose it to scorn with considering
men than his proposal of it;” which therein he owns to be his design. I
know not any peculiar concernment of mine therein, until he comes towards
the close of it; which I shall particularly consider. But the substance of
the religion which he thus avowedly attempts to expose to scorn, is the
doctrine of God’s eternal election; — of his infinite wisdom in sending his
Son to declare his righteousness for the forgiveness of sins, or in
satisfying his justice, that sin might be pardoned, to the praise of the
glory of his grace; — of the imputation of the righteousness of Christ unto
them that do believe; — of a sense of sin, humiliation for it, looking unto
Christ for life and salvation, as the Israelites looked up to the brazen
serpent in the wilderness; — of going to Christ by faith for healing our
natures and cleansing our sins; with some other doctrines of the same
importance. These are the principles which, according to his ability, he
sarcastically traduceth and endeavoureth to reflect scorn upon, by the
false representation of some of them, and debasing others with an
intermixture of vile and profane expressions. It is not impossible but
that some or other may judge it their duty to rebuke this horrible (and yet
were it not for the ignorance and profaneness of some men’s minds, every
way contemptible) petulancy. For my part I have other things to do, and
shall only add, that I know no other Christian state in the world wherein
such discourses would be allowed to pass under the signature of public
authority. Only I wish the author more modesty and sobriety than to
attempt, or suppose he shall succeed, in exposing to scorn the avowed
doctrine in general of the church wherein he lives; and which hath in the
parts of it been asserted and defended by the greatest and most learned
prelates thereof in the foregoing ages, such as Jewell, Whitgift, Abbot, Morton, Usher, Hall, Davenant,
Prideaux, etc., with the most
learned persons of its communion, as Reynolds, Whitaker,
Hooker, Sutcliffe, etc., and others innumerable; —
testified unto in the name of this church by the divines, sent by public
authority to the synod of Dort; — taught by the principal practical divines
of this nation; and maintained by the most learned at the dignified clergy
at this day. He is no doubt at liberty to dissent from the doctrine of the
church, and of all the learned men thereof; but for a young man to suppose
that, with a few loose, idle words, he shall expose to scorn that doctrine
which the persons mentioned, and others innumerable, have not only
explained, confirmed, and defended, with pains indefatigable, all kind of
learning and skill, ecclesiastical, philosophical, and theological, in
books and volumes, which the Christian world as yet knoweth, peruseth, and
prizeth, but also lived long in fervent prayers to God for the revelation
of his mind and truth unto them, and in the holy practice of obedience
suited unto the doctrines they professed, — is somewhat remote
from that Christian humility which he ought not only to exercise in
himself, but to give an example of unto others. But if this be the fruit
of despising the knowledge of the person of Christ, — of the necessity of
his satisfaction, of the imputation of his righteousness, of union unto his
person as our head, — of a sense of the displeasure of God due to sin, — of
the spirit of bondage and adoption, — of the corruption of nature, and our
disability to do any thing that is spiritually good without the effectual
aids of grace; — if these, I say, and the like issues of appearing pride
and elation of mind, be the fruit and consequent of rejecting these
principles of the doctrine of the gospel, it manifests that there is, and
will be, a proportion between the errors of men’s minds and the depravation
of their affections. It were a most easy task to go over all the
particulars mentioned by him, and to manifest how foully he hath
prevaricated in their representation, — how he hath cast contempt on some
duties of religion indispensably necessary unto salvation; and brought in
the very words of the Scripture, — and that in the true proper sense and
intendment of them, according to the judgment of all Christians, ancient
and modern (as that of looking to Christ, as the Israelites looked to the
brazen serpent in the wilderness), — to bear a share and part in his scorn
and contempt: as also, to defend and vindicate, not his odious,
disingenuous expressions, but what he invidiously designeth to expose,
beyond his ability to gainsay, or with any pretence of sober learning to
reply unto. But I give it up into the hands of those who are more
concerned in the chastisement of such imaginations. Only, I cannot but
tell this author what I have learned by long observation, — namely, that
those who, in opposing others, make it their design to [publish] and place
their confidence in false representations, and invidious expressions of
their judgments and opinions, waiving a true stating of the things in
difference, and weighing of the arguments wherewith they are confirmed, —
whatever pretence they may make of confidence, and contempt of them with
whom they have to do, yet this way of writing proceeds from a secret sense
of their disability to maintain their own opinions, or to reply to the
reasonings of their adversaries in a fair and lawful disputation; or from
such depraved affections as are sufficient to deter any sober person from
the least communication in those principles which are so pleaded for. And
the same I must say of that kind of writing (which in some late authors
fills up almost every page in their books) which, beyond a design to load
the persons of men with reproaches and calumnies, consists only in the
collecting of passages here and there, up and down, out of the writings of
others; which, as cut off from the body of their discourses, and design of
the places which they belong unto, may, with a little artifice, either of
addition or detraction, with some false glosses, whereof we
shall have an immediate instance, be represented weak, or untrue, or
improper, or some way or other obnoxious to censure. When diligence,
modesty, love of truth, sobriety, true use of learning, shall again visit
the world in a more plentiful manner; though differences should continue
amongst us, yet men will be enabled to manage them honestly, without
contracting so much guilt on themselves, or giving such fearful offence and
scandal unto others. But I return.