§5. He next marvellously overthrows the unintelligible statements of Eunomius which
assert that the essence of the Father is not separated or divided, and does not become anything
else.
106
“We believe in God,” he tells us, “not separated as regards the essence wherein He is
one, into more than one, or becoming sometimes one and sometimes another, or changing
from being what He is, or passing from one essence to assume the guise of a threefold per-
sonality: for He is always and absolutely one, remaining uniformly and unchangeably the
only God.” From these citations the discreet reader may well separate first of all the idle
words inserted in the statement without any meaning from those which appear to have
some sense, and afterwards examine the meaning that is discoverable in what remains of
his statement, to ascertain whether it is compatible with due reverence towards Christ.
The first, then, of the statements cited is completely divorced from any intelligible
meaning, good or bad. For what sense there is in the words, “not separated, as regards the
essence wherein He is one, into more than one, or becoming sometimes one and sometimes
another, or changing from being what He is,” Eunomius himself could not tell us, and I do
not think that any of his allies could find in the words any shadow of meaning. When he
speaks of Him as “not separated in regard to the essence wherein He is one,” he says either
that He is not separated from His own essence, or that His own essence is not divided from
Him. This unmeaning statement is nothing but a random combination of noise and empty
sound. And why should one spend time in the investigation of these meaningless expressions?
For how does any one remain in existence when separated from his own essence? or how
is the essence of anything divided and displayed apart? Or how is it possible for one to depart
from that wherein he is, and become another, getting outside himself? But he adds, “not
passing from one essence to assume the guise of three persons: for He is always and absolutely
one, remaining uniformly and unchangeably the only God.” I think the absence of meaning
in his statement is plain to every one without a word from me: against this let any one argue
who thinks there is any sense or meaning in what he says: he who has an eye to discern the
force of words will decline to involve himself in a struggle with unsubstantial shadows. For
what force has it against our doctrine to say “not separated or divided into more than one
as regards the essence wherein He is one, or becoming sometimes one and sometimes an-
other, or passing from one essence to assume the guise of three persons?”—things that are
neither said nor believed by Christians nor understood by inference from the truths we
confess. For who ever said or heard any one else say in the Church of God, that the Father
is either separated or divided as regards His essence, or becomes sometimes one, sometimes
another, coming to be outside Himself, or assumes the guise of three persons? These things
Eunomius says to himself, not arguing with us but stringing together his own trash, mixing
with the impiety of his utterances a great deal of absurdity. For we say that it is equally im-
pious and ungodly to call the Lord of the creation a created being and to think that the
He next marvellously overthrows the unintelligible statements of Eunomius which assert that the essence of the Father is not separated or divided, and does not become anything else.
203
He next marvellously overthrows the unintelligible statements of Eunomius…