7. Such an explanation of these passages, as well
as the view here taken of the formula itself, receive abundant
confirmation from S. Gregory Nazianzen and S. Hilary. What has been
maintained is, that when S. Athanasius says, ‘if the Son
is not before His generation, then, &c.,’ he does but
mean, ‘if it can be said,’ ‘if the words can
be used or applied in this case.’ Now the two Fathers just
mentioned both decide that it is not true, either that the Son
was before His generation, or that He was not; in other
words, that the question is unmeaning and irrelevant, which is just the
interpretation which has been here given to Athanasius. But again, in
thus speaking, they thereby assert also that they did not hold,
that they do not allow, that formula which Bull considers the
Nicene Fathers defended and sanctioned, as being Catholic and in use
both before the Council and after, viz. ‘He was before His
generation.’ Thus S. Gregory in the passage in which he speaks of
‘did He that is make Him that is not, &c.,’ and
‘before His generation, &c.,’ as one and the same,
expressly says, ‘In His case, to be begotten is concurrent
with existence and is from the beginning,’ and that in
contrast to the instance of men; who he says, do fulfil in a manner
‘He who is, &c.’ (Levi being in the loins of Abraham),
i.e. fulfil Bull’s proposition, ‘He was before
generation.’ He proceeds, ‘I say that the question is
irrelevant, not the answer difficult.’ And presently after,
mentioning some idle inquiries by way of parallel, he adds, ‘more
ill-instructed, be sure, is it to decide whether what was generated
from the beginning was or was not before generation,
πρὸ τῆς
γεννήσεως.’
Orat. 29. 9.