Let us listen, then, to what he
says. “One might reasonably say that the most proper and primary
essence, and that which alone exists by the operation of the Father,
admits for itself the appellations of ‘product of
generation,’ ‘product of making,’ and ‘product
of creation.’” Who knows not that what separates the Church
from heresy is this term, “product of creation,” applied to
the Son? Accordingly, the doctrinal difference being universally
acknowledged, what would be the reasonable course for a man to take who
endeavours to show that his opinions are more true than ours? Clearly,
to establish his own statement, by showing, by such proofs as he could,
that we ought to consider that the Lord is created. Or omitting
this, should he rather lay down a law for his readers that they should
speak of matters of controversy as if they were acknowledged facts? For
my own part, I think he should take the former course, and perhaps all
who possess any share of intelligence demand this of their opponents,
that they should, to begin with, establish upon some incontrovertible
basis the first principle of their argument, and so proceed to press
their theory by inferences. Now our writer leaves alone the task of
establishing the view that we should think He is created, and goes on
to the next steps, fitting on the inferential process of his argument
to this unproved assumption, being just in the condition of those men
whose minds are deep in foolish desires, with their thoughts wandering
upon a kingdom, or upon some other object of pursuit. They do not think
how any of the things on which they set their hearts could possibly be,
but they arrange and order their good fortune for themselves at their
pleasure, as if it were theirs already, straying with a kind of
pleasure among non-existent things. So, too, our clever author somehow
or other lulls his own renowned dialectic to sleep, and before giving a
demonstration of the point at issue, he tells, as if to children, the
tale of this deceitful and inconsequent folly of his own doctrine,
setting it forth like a story told at a drinking-party. For he says
that the essence which “exists by the operation of the
Father” admits the appellation of “product of
generation,” and of “product of making,” and of
“product of creation.” What reasoning showed us that the
Son exists by any constructive operation, and that the nature of the
Father remains inoperative with regard to the Personal existence ὑπόστασιν of the Son? This was the very point at issue
in the controversy, whether the essence of the Father begat the Son, or
whether it made Him as one of the external things which accompany His
nature At a
later stage Gregory points out that the idea of creation is involved,
if the thing produced is external to the nature of the
Maker.. Now seeing that the Church, according to the
Divine teaching, believes the Only-begotten to be verily God, and
abhors the superstition of polytheism, and for this cause does not
admit the difference of essences, in order that the Godheads may not,
by divergence of essence, fall under the conception of number (for this
is nothing else than to introduce polytheism into our
life)—seeing, I say, that the Church teaches this in plain
language, that the Only-begotten is essentially God, very God of the
essence of the very God, how ought one who opposes her decisions to
overthrow the preconceived opinion? Should he not do so by establishing
the opposing statement, demonstrating the disputed point from some
acknowledged principle? I think no sensible man would look for anything
else than this. But our author starts from the disputed points, and
takes, as though it were admitted, matter which is in controversy as a
principle for the succeeding argument. If it had first been shown that
the Son had His existence through some operation, what quarrel should
we have with what follows, that he should say that the essence which
exists through an operation admits for itself the name of
“product of making”? But let the advocates of error tell us
how the consequence has any force, so long as the antecedent remains
unestablished. For supposing one were to grant by way of hypothesis
that man is winged, there will be no question of concession about what
comes next: for he who becomes winged will fly in some way or other,
and lift himself up on high above the earth, soaring through the air on
his wings. But we have to see how he whose nature is not aerial could
become winged, and if this condition does not exist, it is vain to
discuss the next point. Let our author, then, show this to begin with,
that it is in vain that the Church has believed that the Only-begotten
Son truly exists, not adopted by a Father falsely so called, but
existing according to nature, by generation from Him Who is, not
alienated from the essence of Him that begat Him. But so long as his
primary proposition remains unproved, it is idle to dwell on those
which are secondary. And let no one interrupt me, by saying that what
we confess should also be confirmed by constructive reasoning: for it
is enough for proof of our statement, that the tradition has come down
to us from our fathers, handed on, like some inheritance, by succession
from the apostles and the saints who came after them. They, on the
other hand, who change their doctrines to this novelty, would need the
support of arguments in abundance, if they were about to bring over to
their views, not men light as dust, and unstable, but men of weight and
steadiness: but so long as their statement is advanced without being
established, and without being proved, who is so foolish and so brutish
as to account the teaching of the evangelists and apostles, and of
those who have successively shone like lights in the churches, of less
force than this undemonstrated nonsense?