Chap. IV.
9. You have now heard what manner of person you should be if you would pray; hear,
in the next place, what you ought to pray for. This is the subject on which you have thought
it most necessary to ask my opinion, because you were disturbed by the words of the apostle:
“We know not what we should pray for as we ought;”2446 and you became alarmed lest it
should do you more harm to pray otherwise than you ought, than to desist from praying
altogether. A short solution of your difficulty may be given thus: “Pray for a happy life.”
This all men wish to have; for even those whose lives are worst and most abandoned would
by no means live thus, unless they thought that in this way they either were made or might
be made truly happy. Now what else ought we to pray for than that which both bad and
good desire, but which only the good obtain?
Chap. V.
10. You ask, perchance, What is this happy life? On this question the talents and leisure
of many philosophers have been wasted, who, nevertheless, failed in their researches after
it just in proportion as they failed to honour Him from whom it proceeds, and were unthank-
ful to Him. In the first place, then, consider whether we should accept the opinion of those
philosophers who pronounce that man happy who lives according to his own will. Far be
it, surely, from us to believe this; for what if a man’s will inclines him to live in wickedness?
Is he not proved to be a miserable man in proportion to the facility with which his depraved
will is carried out? Even philosophers who were strangers to the worship of God have rejected
this sentiment with deserved abhorrence. One of them, a man of the greatest eloquence,
says: “Behold, however, others, not philosophers indeed, but men of ready power in dispu-
tation, who affirm that all men are happy who live according to their own will. But this is
certainly untrue, for to wish that which is unbecoming is itself a most miserable thing; nor
is it so miserable a thing to fail in obtaining what you wish as to wish to obtain what you
ought not to desire.”2447 What is your opinion? Are not these words, by whomsoever they
are spoken, derived from the Truth itself? We may therefore here say what the apostle said
of a certain Cretan poet2448 whose sentiment had pleased him: “This witness is true.”2449
11. He, therefore, is truly happy who has all that he wishes to have, and wishes to have
nothing which he ought not to wish. This being understood, let us now observe what things
men may without impropriety wish to have. One desires marriage; another, having become
a widower, chooses thereafter to live a life of continence; a third chooses to practise contin-
ence though he is married. And although of these three conditions one may be found better
2446 Rom. viii. 26.
2447 Cicero Hortensius.
2448 Epimenides.
2449 Titus i. 13.
997
To Proba