1. Since you have refused to believe your own ears, I
might justly decline to satisfy you by a letter; for, if you have
failed to credit the living voice, it is not likely that you will give
way to a written paper. But, since Christ has shown us in Himself a
pattern of perfect humility, bestowing a kiss upon His betrayer and
receiving the robber’s repentance upon the cross, I tell you now
when absent as I have told you already when present, that I read and
have read Origen only as I read Apollinaris, or other writers whose
books in some things the Church does not receive. I by no means say
that everything contained in such books is to be condemned, but I admit
that there are things in them deserving of censure. Still, as it is my
task and study by reading many authors to cull different flowers from
as large a number as possible, not so much making it an object to prove
all things as to choose what are good. I take up many writers that from
the many I may learn many things; according to that which is written
“reading all things, holding fast those that are good.” 1 Th. v. 21. “Prove all things,” Vulg.
and A.V. Hence I am much surprised that you have tried
to fasten upon me the doctrines of Origen, of whose mistaken teaching
on many points you are up to the present altogether unaware. Am I a
heretic? Why pray then do heretics dislike me so? And are you orthodox,
you who either against your convictions and the words of your own mouth
signed Probably Aterbius (for
whom see Jerome Apol. iii. 33, and note on Letter LXXXVI.) had brought
with him some test-formula of orthodoxy which he called upon all
anti-Origenists to sign. unwillingly and are consequently a
prevaricator, or else signed deliberately and are consequently a
heretic? You have taken no account of Egypt; you have relinquished all
those provinces where numbers plead freely and openly for your sect;
and you have singled out me for assault, me who not only censure but
publicly condemn all doctrines that are contrary to the church.