(3.) The history of Athanasius during this period
is the history of his writings. Hidden from all but devotedly loyal
eyes, whether in the cells of Nitria and the Thebaid, or lost in the
populous solitude of his own city, he followed with a keen and
comprehensive glance the march of events outside. Two men in this age
had skill to lay the physician’s finger upon the pulse of
religious conviction; Hilary, the Western who had learned to understand
and sympathise with the East, Athanasius, the Oriental representative
of the theological instincts of the West. First of all came the
writings of which we have spoken, the circular to the bishops and the
Apology to Constantius; then the dignified Apology for his flight,
written not long before the expulsion of George late in 358, when he
had begun to realise the merciless enmity and profound duplicity of the
Emperor. We find him not long after this in correspondence with the
exiled confessor, Lucifer of Calaris (pp. 561 sq., 481
sqq.), and warning the Egyptian monks against compromising
relations with Arian visitors (Letter 53, a document of high
interest), narrating to the trusted Serapion the facts as to the death
of Arius, and sending to the monks a concise refutation of Arian
doctrine (Letters 52, 54). With the latter is associated a
reissue of the Apology of 351, and, as a continuation of it, the
solitary monument of a less noble spirit which Athanasius has left us,
the one work which we would gladly believe to have come from any other
pen He always
used amanuenses, but we have no evidence that he entrusted them with
actual composition, p. 242.. But this supposition is untenable, and in the
ferocious pamphlet against Constantius known as the Arian
History we are reminded that noble as he was, our saint yet lived
in an age of fierce passions and reckless personal violence. The
Arian History has its noble features—no work of Athanasius
could lack them—but it reveals not the man himself but his
generation; his exasperation, and the meanness of his persecutors. (For
details on all these tracts see the Introductions and notes to them.)
None of the above books directly relate to the doctrinal developments
sketched above. But these developments called forth the three greatest
works of his exile, and indeed of his whole career. Firstly, the
four Λόγοι or
Tracts against Arianism, his most famous dogmatic work. Of these
an account will be given in the proper place, but it may be noticed
here that they are evidently written with a conciliatory as well as a
controversial purpose, and in view of the position between 357 and 359.
Next, the four dogmatic letters to Serapion, the second
of which reproduces the substance of his position against the Arians,
while the other three are devoted to a question overlooked in the
earlier stages of the controversy, the Coessentiality of the Holy
Spirit. This work may possibly have come after the third, and in
some ways the most striking, of the series, the de Synodis
written about the end of 359, and intended as a formal offer of peace
to the Homœusian party. Following as it did closely upon the
conciliatory work of Hilary, who was present at Seleucia on the side of
the majority, this magnanimous Eirenicon produced an immediate effect,
which we trace in the letters of the younger Basil written in the same
or following year; but the full effect and justification of the book is
found in the influence exerted by Athanasius upon the new orthodoxy
which eventually restored the ‘ten provinces’ to ‘the
knowledge of God’ (Hil. de Syn. 63. Further details in
Introd. to de Syn., infra, p. 448. It may be remarked that the
romantic idea of his secret presence at Seleucia, and even at Ariminum,
must be dismissed as a too rigid inference from an expression used by
him in that work: see note 1 there).