CHAP. XIX.] THE SPIRIT IS EQUAL TO THE FATHER. 421
the Holy Spirit is the gift of God, in so far as He is given to
those who by Him love God. But it is too long a task to
collect them all. And what is enough to satisfy those who
are not satisfied with those we have alleged ?
36. Certainly they must be warned, since they now see
that the Holy Spirit is called the gift of God, that when they
hear of " the gift of the Holy Spirit," they should recognise
therein that mode of speech which is found in the words,
" In the spoiling of the body of the flesh." ^ For as the body
of the flesh is nothing else but the flesh, so the gift of the
Holy Spirit is nothing else but the Holy Spirit. He is then
the gift of God, so far as He is given to those to whom He is
given. But in Himself He is God, althoughHe were given to
no one, because He was God co-eternal with the Father and
the Son before He was given to any one. Nor is He less
than they, because they give, and He is given. For He is
given as a gift of God in such way thatHe Himself also gives
Himself as being God. For He cannot be said not to be in
His own power, of whom it is said, " The Spirit bloweth where
it listeth;"^ and in the apostle, as I have already mentioned
above, *' All these things worketh that selfsame Spirit, dividing
to every man severally as He will." We have not here the
creating of Him that is given, and the rule of them that give,
but the concord of the given and the givers.
37. Wherefore, if Holy Scripture proclaims that God is
love, and that love is of God, and works this in us that we
abide in God and He in us, and that hereby we know this,
because He has given us of His Spirit, then the Spirit Himself
is God, who is love. Next, if there be among the gifts of
God none greater than love, and there is no greater gift of
God than the Holy Spirit, what follows more naturally than
that He is Himself love, who is called both God and of God ?
And if the love by which the Father loves the Son, and thel
Son loves the Father, ineffably demonstrates the communion
of both,what is more suitable than, that He should be specially
called love, who is the Spirit common to both ? For this is
the sounder thing both to believe and to understand, that the
Holy Spirit is not alone love in that Trinity, yet is not
1 Col. ii. 11. 2 John iii. 6.