6. O. Your memory has served you, and you have certainly
given us at great length many quotations from the sacred books: but
after going all round the wood, you are caught in my hunting-nets. Let
the case be as you would have it, that an Arian bishop is the enemy of
Christ, let him be the salt that has lost its savour, let him be a lamp
without flame, let him be an eye without a pupil: no doubt your
argument will take you thus far—that he cannot salt another who
himself has no salt: a blind man cannot enlighten others, nor set them
on fire when his own light has gone out. But why, when you swallow food
which he has seasoned, do you reproach the seasoned with being
saltless? Your Church is bright with his flame, and do you accuse his
lamp of being extinguished? He gives you eyes, and are you blind?
Wherefore, I pray you, either give him the power of sacrificing since
you approve his baptism, or reject his baptism if you do not think him
a priest. For it is impossible that he who is holy in baptism should be
a sinner at the altar.