The point at issue between the two
interpretations is this; whether the clause πρὶν
γεννηθῆναι
οὐκ ἦν is intended for a
denial of the contrary proposition, ‘He was before
His generation,’ as Bishop Bull says; or whether it is what
Aristotle calls an enthymematic sentence, assuming the falsity,
as confessed on all hands, of that contrary proposition, as
self-contradictory, and directly denying, not it, but ‘He was
from everlasting.’ Or, in other words, whether it opposes the
position of the five writers, or the great Catholic doctrine itself;
and whether in consequence the Nicene Fathers are in their anathema
indirectly sanctioning that position, or stating that doctrine. Bull
considers that both sides contemplated the proposition,
‘He was before His generation,’—and that the
Catholics asserted or defended it; some reasons shall here be given for
the contrary view.