After the Pope Vigilius of illustrious memory,
having been appointed in the royal city Vigilius,
having gone to Constantinople with pope Agapetus, who died there, was
selected by the Empress Theodora as his successor, and sent back to
Italy with an order from her to Belisarius to bring about his election
(Liberatus, Breviar. c. 22). Gregory seems to have been
unaware of the fact stated by Liberatus, namely that Vigilius had come
to a secret understanding with the Empress that he would support the
Monophysite party and disallow the Council of Chalcedon, as there is
good evidence that he did after his accession. It is true that he
afterwards declared for orthodoxy, and condemned all abettors of the
Eutychian heresy. But this appears to have been not till
a.d. 540, in reply to a letter received from
the Emperor Justinian and therefore subsequent to the occupation of
Rome by the Gothic King Theodatus, which was in 536, and to its siege
by Vitiges, who retired in 538. Thus what Gregory goes on to say
about Rome having been attacked and captured by enemies after the
condemnation of heresy by Vigilius must be due to serious ignorance of
the facts of the case. Nor does he appear to have known—at
any rate he does not intimate—that the condemnation of the Three
Chapters, pressed upon the fifth Council by the Emperor Justinian, had
been in spite of the opposition of Vigilius, though it is true that
this sorry pope did afterwards assent to it.,
promulgated a sentence of condemnation against Theodora, then empress,
or against the Acephali The
Monophysites—or some of them—had come to be so called, as
being without a head, after their leader, Peter Mongus, had accepted
the See of Alexandria on the doctrinal basis of Zeno’s
Henoticon., the city of Rome
was then attacked and captured by enemies. Does it follow from
this that the Acephali had a good case, or that they were unjustly
condemned, because such things happened after their condemnation?
Away with the thought! For it is not fit that either any one of
you, or any others who have been instituted in the mysteries of the
Catholic Faith, should say or in any way acknowledge this. This
then being recognized, retire ye even now at length from the
determination you have come to. Wherefore, that full satisfaction
may be infused into your minds, and all doubt removed, with respect to
the three chapters, I have judged it of advantage to send you the book
which my predecessor of holy memory, Pope Pelagius, had written on this
subject Pelagius I., who
succeeded Vigilius, though he had formerly with him opposed the
condemnation of the Three Chapters, upheld it after his accession to
the popedom. The “book” sent by Gregory to the
bishops may have been the Epistle given as Ep. VII., among those
attributed to Pelagius, addressed to Helias and the bishops of
Istria.. Which
book if you should be willing to read again and again, putting aside
the spirit of wilful self-defence, I have confidence that you will
follow it in all respects, and, notwithstanding all, return to union
with us. But if henceforth, after perusal of this book, you
should decide to persist in your present determination, you will
doubtless shew that you gave yourselves up not to reason but to
obstinacy. Wherefore once more, in a spirit of compassion, I
admonish your Charity, that, inasmuch as under God the
purity
of our faith has remained inviolate in the matter of the Three
Chapters, ye put away from you all swelling of mind, and return to your
mother the Church, who expects and invites her sons; and this all the
more speedily as you know that she expects you daily.