SECT. IV.
Of the distinction of natural and moral Necessity, and Inability.
That Necessity which has been explained, consisting in an infallible connexion of the
things signified by the subject and predicate of a proposition, as intelligent beings are the
subjects of it, is distinguished into moral and natural Necessity.
I shall not now stand to inquire whether this distinction be a proper and perfect distinc-
tion; but shall only explain how these two sorts of Necessity are understood, as the terms
are sometimes used, and as they are used in the following discourse.
The phrase, moral Necessity, is used variously: sometimes it is used for a Necessity of
moral obligation. So we say, a man is under Necessity, when he is under bonds of duty and
conscience, from which he cannot be discharged. Again, the word Necessity is often used
for great obligation in point of interest. Sometimes by moral Necessity is meant that apparent
connexion of things, which is the ground of moral evidence; and so is distinguished from
absolute Necessity, or that sure connexion of things, that is a foundation for infallible certainty.
In this sense, moral Necessity signifies much the same as that high degree of probability,
which is ordinarily sufficient to satisfy mankind, in their conduct and behavior in the world,
as they would consult their own safety and interest, and treat others properly as members
of society. And sometimes by moral Necessity is meant that Necessity of connexion and
consequence, which arises from such moral causes, as the strength of inclination, or motives,
and the connexion which there is in many cases between these and such certain volitions
and actions. And it is in this sense, that I use the phrase, moral necessity, in the following
discourse.
By natural Necessity, as applied to men, I mean such Necessity as men are under through
the force of natural causes; as distinguished from what are called moral causes, such as habits
and dispositions of the heart, and moral motives and inducements. Thus men, placed in
certain circumstances, are the subjects of particular sensations by Necessity: they feel pain
when their bodies are wounded; they see the objects presented before them in a clear light,
when their eyes are opened: so they assent to the truth of certain propositions, as soon as
the terms are understood; as that two and two make four, that black is not white, that two
parallel lines can never cross one another; so by a natural Necessity men’s bodies move
downwards, when there is nothing to support them.
But here several things may be noted concerning these two kinds of Necessity.
1. Moral Necessity may be as absolute as natural Necessity. That is, the effect may be as
perfectly connected with its moral cause, as a natural, necessary effect is with its natural
cause. Whether the Will in every case is necessarily determined by the strongest motive, or
whether the Will ever makes any resistance to such a motive, or can ever oppose the strongest
present inclination, or not; if that matter should be controverted, yet I suppose none will
deny, but that, in some cases, a previous bias and inclination, or the motive presented, may
SECTION IV Of the distinction of natural and moral Necessity, and Inability.
534
SECTION IV Of the distinction of natural and moral Necessity, and Inability.…