PROLEGOMENA TO JEROME. xxi
from Paradise." His intemperateness, which threw contempt upon marriage, was severely blamed by his friends at Rome, who tried to stop the publication (79 ; see also Ruf. Apol. ii.
44, Vol. iii. 480) ; but he only replied by renewed expressions of derision, and, several years
later, when he has occasion to refer to Jovinian, he says, "This man, after being condemned
by the authority of the Roman Church, amidst his feasts of pheasants and swine's flesh, I will
not say gave up, but belched out, his life " (417). 393-403. (2) Origenism. The second great controversy in which Jerome was engaged at this period relates to Origenism, about which a great controversy had arisen at
Alexandria, leading to its condemnation by the Bishops of Palestine and Cyprus in the East,
and by the Pope and the Bishop of Milan and others in the West.
The great church teacher of Alexandria in the third century was but little known in the
West. Anastasius the Pope, in the year 399, declared that he neither knew who he was nor
what he had written (Vol. iii. 433). Jerome, who had made acquaintance with his writings
during his first sojourn in the East, conceived a strong admiration for him ; he did not,
indeed, accept all his views, as may be seen from the first letter in which he alludes to him
(22) ; but on his coming to Rome he did all in his power to make him known. He was
invited by Damasus to translate some of his works (485) ; and when he found ignorant con-
demnations passed upon him he praised him with his usual vehemence and without discrim-
ination, even eulogizing the Ilspl 'Apx^v on which the subsequent controversy mainly turned (46 ; Ruf. Ap. ii. 13, Vol. iii. 467). He had also quoted without blame in his. Commentary
on the Ephesians statements such as those relating to the pre-existence of human souls and
the possible restoration of Satan (Ruf. Apol. i. 448, 454). But it was rather a literary enthu-
siasm and an admiration of original genius than an express consent to Origen's system. His calm judgment in later years was, that his literary services to the Church were inestimable,
but that his doctrinal views were to be read with the greatest caution, and that those specially
impugned were heretical (176, 177, 238, 244). It must be allowed, however, that he appears
in his earlier stage as the vehement panegyrist of Origen (46, 48), and in his later stage as
his equally vehement condemner ; and also that this change seems less the effect of convic-
tion than of a fear of the imputation of heresy (Apol. iii. 33, Vol. iii. 535).
The monks in the deserts near Alexandria were divided, some holding Origenistic views,
and some those of an opposite tendency and verging upon Anthropomorphism. Theophilus,
the Bishop of Alexandria, at first sided with the Origenists, but afterwards turned against
them, and became their relentless persecutor. During his former phase he was appealed to
by John, Bishop of Jerusalem, in his controversy with Epiphanius and Jerome (427), and took
his part so vehemently that he sent his confidant Isidore to Jerusalem, nominally to inquire,
but really to crush out all opposition, as he stated in a letter to John (444). This letter fell
into the hands of Jerome and his friends, and the intentions of Theophilus were frustrated.
A period of suspicious silence followed (134) ; but when Theophilus had undergone his
change he found a ready instrument in Jerome, who threw himself eagerly into the conflict
(182-184), translated the encyclicals of Theophilus (185, 186, 189) which led to the condem- nation of Origen in the East, and even his diatribe against St. John Chrysostom for receiving
Isidore and his brethren, whom Theophilus now treated as his enemies (214). Jerome also,
through his friends Pammachius, Marcella, and Eusebius (186, 256), procured the condem- nation of Origen in the West.
(3) John of Jerusalem. The controversy with John of Jerusalem forms an episode in the more general controversy. John had been trained among the Origenistic ascetics,
Epiphanius among the anti-Origenists. Jerome appears to have undergone no change in his
sentiments as to Origen during the first period of his stay at Bethlehem [see his Preface to
the Book of Hebrew Questions (486, 487) written in 388], and was on good terms with the
Bishop of Jerusalem and with Rufinus, who was then living on the Mount of
393. Olives. But at the beginning of the second period a certain Aterbius came to
Jerusalem and spread suspicion and alarm of heresy. Jerome, herhaps weakly,
" gave him satisfaction " as to his faith (Apol. iii. 33, Vol. iii. 535), while by John and Rufinus
he was treated as a busybody (id.}. This produced the first estrangement, which was
394. greatly increased by the visit of Epiphanius in the following year. The scenes which
followed may be read in Jerome's treatise " Against John of Jerusalem " (430) and in
Epiphanius' letter translated by Jerome (83-85). Epiphanius was popular at Jerusalem, and after a scene in the church, in which he preached against Origenism and John against Anthropo-
morphism, a breach was made between the two prelates. Epiphanius came to stay at Bethle-
hem, and spoke of John as well nigh a heretic. John spoke of Epiphanius as " that old
dotard " (430). The monks of Bethlehem took part with Epiphanius ; and he, to prevent their