The treatise is a letter to Pammachius, who had been
disturbed by the complaints of Bishop John to Siricius, bishop of Rome,
against Jerome. Jerome begins (1) by pleading necessity for his attack
on the bishop. Epiphanius has accused him of heresy (2). Let him answer
plainly (3), for it is pride alone (4) which prevents this. It is said
that John’s letter of explanation or apology was approved by
Theophilus (5); but it did not touch the point, that is, the accusation
of Origenism. Only three points are treated (6), and Epiphanius adduced
eight—namely (7) Origen’s opinions (i.) that the Son does
not see the Father; (ii.) that souls are confined in earthly bodies, as
in a prison; (iii.) that the devil may be saved; (iv.) that the skins
with which God clothed Adam and Eve were human bodies; (v.) that the
body in the resurrection will be without sex; (vi.) that the
descriptions of Paradise are allegorical: trees meaning angels, and
rivers the heavenly virtues; (vii) that the waters above and below the
firmament are angels and devils; (viii.) that the image of God was
altogether lost at the Fall. John, instead of answering on the first
head, merely expressed his faith in the Trinity (8, 9), and all through
tries to make out (10) that the question between him and Epiphanius
relates merely to the ordination of Paulinianus. Jerome then relates
the extraordinary scenes of the altercation between Epiphanius and John
(11–14). He then turns to the Origenistic notions that angels are
cast down into human souls (15, 16), that the spirits of men pass into
the heavenly bodies (17) and that the souls of men had a previous
existence (18), and pass up and down in the scale of creation (19, 20).
John, instead of answering on these points, contents himself with
protesting against Manichæism
(21.) Jerome presses him on the question of the origin of souls (22),
pronouncing rashly for creationism. He then passes to the question of
the state of the body after the resurrection (23), asserting the
restoration of the flesh as it now is (24–27), both in the
case of Christ (28) and in our own, adducing testimonies from the Old
Testament (29–32), and discussing the appearances of our Lord
after His resurrection (34–36). He then passes to a detailed
examination of John’s letter or “Apology” to
Theophilus (37), quoting its words, and telling the story of the
mission of Isidore (37, 38), and the attempts of the Count Archelaus to
make peace (39). The ordination of Paulinianus, on which John lays
stress, is a subterfuge (40, 41). The schism is due to the heretical
tendencies of the bishop, who is everywhere denounced by Epiphanius
(42, 43).