6. Timothy, so it is recorded, was the first to receive the episcopate of the parish in
Ephesus,607 Titus of the churches in Crete.608
607 That Timothy was the first bishop of Ephesus is stated also by the Apost. Const. (VII. 46), and by Nice-
phorus (H. E. III. 11), who records (upon what authority we do not know) that he suffered martyrdom under
Domitian. Against the tradition that he labored during his later years in Ephesus there is nothing to be urged;
though on the other hand the evidence for it amounts to little, as it seems to be no more than a conclusion drawn
from the Epistles to Timothy, though hardly a conclusion drawn by Eusebius himself, for he uses the word
ἱστορεῖται, which seems to imply that he had some authority for his statement. According to those epistles, he
was at the time of their composition in Ephesus, though they give us no hint as to whether he was afterward
there or not. From Heb. xiii. 23 (the date of which we do not know) we learn that he had just been released from
some imprisonment, apparently in Italy, but whither he afterward went is quite uncertain. Eusebius’ report that
he was bishop of Ephesus is the customary but unwarranted carrying back into the first century of the monarch-
ical episcopate which was not known until the second. According to the Apost. Const. VII. 46 both Timothy and
John were bishops of Ephesus, the former appointed by Paul, the latter by himself. Timothy is a saint in the
Roman Catholic sense, and is commemorated January 24.
608 Cf. Tit. i. 5. Titus is commonly connected by tradition with Crete, of which he is supposed to have been
the first bishop,—the later institution being again pushed back into the first century. In the fragment de Vita et
Actis Titi, by the lawyer Zenas (in Fabric. Cod. Apoc. N.T. II. 831 sqq., according to Howson, in Smith’s Dict. of
the Bible), he is said to have been bishop of Gortyna, a city of Crete (where still stand the ruins of a church which
bears his name), and of a royal Cretan family by birth. This tradition is late, and, of course, of little authority,
but at the same time, accords very well with all that we know of Titus; and consequently there is no reason for
denying it in toto. According to 2 Tim. iv. 10, he went, or was sent, into Dalmatia; but universal tradition ascribes
his later life and his death to Crete. Candia, the modern capital, claims the honor of being his burial place (see
Cave’sApostolici, ed. 1677, p. 63). Titus is a saint, in the Roman Catholic sense, and is commemorated January
4.
261
The First Successors of the Apostles.