237
Book XVIII.
The relation of Christ to prophecy, continued.
1. Faustus said: "I came not to destroy the law, but to fulfill it." If these are Christ’s
words, unless they have some other meaning, they are as much against you as against me.
Your Christianity as well as mine is based on the belief that Christ came to destroy the law
and the prophets. Your actions prove this, even though in words you deny it. It is on this
ground that you disregard the precepts of the law and the prophets. It is on this ground
that we both acknowledge Jesus as the founder of the New Testament, in which is implied
the acknowledgment that the Old Testament is destroyed. How, then, can we believe that
Christ said these words without first confessing that hitherto we have been wholly in error,
and without showing our repentance by entering on a course of obedience to the law and
the prophets, and of careful observance of their requirements, whatever they may be? This
done, we may honestly believe that Jesus said that he came not to destroy the law, but to
fulfill it. As it is, you accuse me of not believing what you do not believe yourself, and what
therefore is false.
2. But grant that we have been in the wrong hitherto. What is to be done now? Shall
we come under the law, since Christ has not destroyed, but fulfilled it? Shall we by circum-
cision add shame to shame, and believe that God is pleased with such sacraments? Shall we
observe the rest of the Sabbath, and bind ourselves in the fetters of Saturn? Shall we glut
the demon of the Jews, for he is not God, with the slaughter of bulls, rams, and goats, not
to say of men; and adopt, only with greater cruelty, in obedience to the law and the prophets,
the practices on account of which we abandoned idolatry? Shall we, in fine, call the flesh
of some animals clean, and that of others unclean, among which, according to the law and
the prophets, swine’s flesh has a particular defilement? Of course you will allow that as
Christians we must not do any of these things, for you remember that Christ says that a
man when circumcised becomes twofold a child of hell. 650 It is plain also that Christ neither
observed the Sabbath himself, nor commanded it to be observed. And regarding foods, he
says expressly that man is not defiled by anything that goes into his mouth, but rather by
the things which come out of it.651 Regarding sacrifices, too, he often says that God desires
mercy, and not sacrifice.652 What becomes, then, of the statement that he came not to
destroy the law, but to fulfill it? If Christ said this, he must have meant something else, or,
what is not to be thought of, he told a lie, or he never said it. No Christian will allow that
Jesus spoke falsely; therefore he must either not have said this, or said it with another
meaning.
650 Matt. xxiii. 15.
651 Matt. xv. 11.
652 Matt. ix. 13.
The relation of Christ to prophecy, continued.
405
The relation of Christ to prophecy, continued.