This being the view held by all
who accept in its simplicity the undiluted Gospel, what occasion was
there for endeavouring to dissolve this fast union of the Son with the
Father by means of the creation, as if it were necessary to suppose
either that the Son was from everlasting along with the creation, or
that He too, equally with it, was later? For the generation of the Son
does not fall within time The
generation of the Son does not fall within time. On this “eternal generation” Denys (De la
Philosophie d’Origéne, p. 452) has the following
remarks, illustrating the probable way that Athanasians would have
dealt with Eunomius: “If we do not see how God’s
indivisibility remains in the co-existence of the three Persons, we can
throw the blame of this difficulty upon the feebleness of our reason:
while it is a manifest contradiction to admit at one and the same time
the simplicity of the Uncreated, and some change or inequality within
His Being. I know that the defenders of the orthodox belief might be
troubled with their adversaries’ argument. (Eunom. Apol. 22.)
‘If we admit that the Son, the energy creative of the world, is
equal to the Father, it amounts to admitting that He is the actual
energy of the Father in Creation, and that this energy is equal to His
essence. But that is to return to the mistake of the Greeks who
identified His essence and His energy, and consequently made the world
coexist with God.’ A serious difficulty, certainly, and one that
has never yet been solved, nor will be; as all the questions likewise
which refer to the Uncreated and Created, to eternity and time. It is
true we cannot explain how God’s eternally active energy does
prolong itself eternally. But what is this difficulty compared with
those which, with the hypothesis of Eunomius, must be swallowed? We
must suppose, so, that the ᾽Αγέννητος, since His energy is not eternal, became in a given
place and moment, and that He was at that point the Γεννητός. We must suppose that this activity communicated to a
creature that privilege of the Uncreated which is most incommunicable,
viz. the power of creating other creatures. We must suppose that these
creatures, unconnected as they are with the ᾽Αγέννητος
(since He has not made them), nevertheless conceive of
and see beyond their own creator a Being, who cannot be anything to
them. [This direct intuition on our part of the Deity was a special
tenet of Eunomius.] Finally we must suppose that these creatures,
seeing that Eunomius agrees with orthodox believers that the end of
this world will be but a commencement, will enter into new relations
with this ᾽Αγέννητος, when the Son shall have submitted all things to the
Father.”, any more than the
creation was before time: so that it can in no kind of way be right to
partition the indivisible, and to insert, by declaring that there was a
time when the Author of all existence was not, this false idea of time
into the creative Source of the Universe.