With what eyes will you now dare
to gaze upon your guide? I speak to you, O flock O
flock. This could not have been written
earlier than 384, and there is abundant testimony that Eunomius still
had his “flock.” Long before this, even soon after he had
left his see of Cyzicus, and had taken up his abode with Eudoxius, he
separated himself from that champion of the Homœan party, and held
assemblies apart because he had repeatedly entreated that his preceptor
Aetius might be received into communion (Socrates iv. 13). This must
have been about 366, before his banishment by Valens for favouring the
rebellion of Procopius. Sozomen says (vi. 29), “The heresy of
Eunomius was spread from Cilicia and the Mountains of Taurus as far as
the Hellespont and Constantinople.” In 380 at Bithynia near
Constantinople “multitudes resorted to him, some also gathered
from other quarters, a few with the design of testing his principles,
and others merely from the desire of listening to his discourses. His
reputation reached the ears of the Emperor, who would gladly have had a
conference with him. But the Empress Flacilla studiously prevented an
interview taking place between them; for she was the most faithful
guard of the Nicene doctrines” (vii. 17). At the convention,
however, of all the sects at Theodosius’ palace in 382, Eunomius
was present (Socrates v. 10). His ἔκθεσις τῆς
πίστεως (to
which he added learned notes) was laid before Theodosius in 383. It was
not till 391 that the Emperor condemned him to banishment—the
sole exception to Theodosius’ toleration. “This
heretic,” says Sozomen again, “had fixed his residence in
the suburbs of Constantinople and held frequent assemblies in private
houses, where he read his own writings. He induced many to embrace his
sentiments, so that the sectarians who were named after him became very
numerous. He died not long after his banishment, and was interred at
Dacora, his birthplace, a village of Cappadocia.” of perishing souls! How can
you still turn to listen to this man who has reared such a monument as
this of his shamelessness in argument? Are ye not ashamed now, at
least, if not before, to take the hand of a man like this to lead you
to the truth? Do ye not regard it as a sign of his madness as to
doctrine, that he thus shamelessly stands out against the truth
contained in Scripture? Is this the way to play the champion of the
truth of doctrine—namely, to accuse Basil of deriving the God
over all from that which has absolutely no existence? Am I to tell the
way he phrases it? Am I to transcribe the very words of his
shamelessness? I let the insolence of them pass; I do not blame their
invective, for I do not censure one whose breath is of bad odour,
because it is of bad odour; or one who has bodily mutilation, because
he is mutilated. Things such as that are the misfortunes of nature;
they escape blame from those who can reflect. This strength of
vituperation, then, is infirmity in reasoning; it is an affliction of a
soul whose powers of sound argument are marred. No word from me, then,
about his invectives. But as to that syllogism, with its stout
irrefragable folds, in whose conclusion, to effect his darling object,
he arrives at this accusation against us, I will write it out in its
own precise words. “We will allow him to say that the Son exists
by participation in the self-existent τοῦ ὄντος;
but (instead of this), he has unconsciously affirmed that the God over
all comes from absolute nonentity. For if the idea of the absence of
everything amounts to that of absolute nonentity τὸ μηδὲν τῷ
πάντη μὴ ὄντι
ταὐτὸν., and the transposition of equivalents is
perfectly legitimate, then the man who says that God comes from nothing
says that He comes from nonentity.” To which of these statements
shall we first direct our attention? Shall we criticize his opinion
about the Son “existing by participation” in the Deity, and
his bespattering those who will not acquiesce in it with the foulness
of his tongue; or shall we examine the sophism so frigidly constructed
from the stuff of dreams? However, every one who possesses a spark of
practical sagacity is not unaware that it is only poets and moulders of
mythology who father sons “by participation” upon the
Divine Being. Those, that is, who string together the myths in their
poems, fabricate a Dionysus, or a Hercules, or a Minos, and such-like,
out of the combination of the superhuman with human bodies; and they
exalt such personages above the rest of mankind, representing them as
of greater estimation because of their participation in a superior
nature. Therefore, with regard to this opinion of his, carrying as it
does within itself the evidence of its own folly and profanity, it is
best to be silent; and to repeat instead that irrefragable syllogism of
his, in order that every poor ignoramus on our side may understand what
and how many are the advantages which those who are not trained in his
technical methods are deprived of. He says, “If the idea of the
absence of everything amounts to that of absolute nonentity, and the
transposition of equivalents is perfectly legitimate, then the man who
says that God comes from nothing, says that He comes from
nonentity.” He brandishes over us this Aristotelian weapon, but
who has yet conceded to him, that to say that any one has no father
amounts to saying that he has been generated from absolute nonentity?
He who enumerates those persons whose line is recorded in Scripture is
plainly thinking of a father preceding each person mentioned. For what
relation is Heli to Joseph? What relation is Matthat to Heli? And what
relation is Adam to Seth? Is it not plain to a mere child that this
catalogue of names is a list of fathers? For if Seth is the son of
Adam, Adam must be the father of one thus born from him; and so tell
me, who is the father of the Deity Who is over all? Come, answer this
question, open your lips and speak, exert all your skill in expression
to meet such an inquiry. Can you discover any expression that will
elude the grasp of your own syllogism? Who is the father of the
Ungenerate? Can you say? If you can, then He is not ungenerate. Pressed
thus, you will say, what indeed necessity compels you to say,—No
one is. Well, my dear sir, do you not yet find the weak seams of your
sophism giving way? Do you not perceive that you have slavered upon
your own lap? What says our great Basil? That the Ungenerate One is
from no father. For the conclusion to be drawn from the mention
of fathers in the preceding genealogy permits the word father, even in
the silence of the evangelist, to be added to this confession of faith.
Whereas, you have transformed “no one” into “nothing
at all,” and again “nothing at all” into
“absolute nonentity,” thereby concocting that fallacious
syllogism of yours. Accordingly this clever result of professional
shrewdness shall be turned against yourself. I ask, Who
is the father of the Ungenerate One? “No one,” you will
be obliged to answer; for the Ungenerate One cannot have a father.
Then, if no one is the father of the Ungenerate, and you have changed
“no one” into “nothing at all,” and
“nothing at all” is, according to your argument, the same
as “absolute nonentity,” and the transposition of
equivalents is, as you say, perfectly legitimate, then the man
(i.e. you) who says that no one is the father of the Ungenerate
One, says that the Deity Who is over all comes from absolute
nonentity!