38. Now are they not worthy of all hatred for
merely uttering this? for if, as they hold, He is Son, not because He
is begotten of the Father and proper to His Essence, but that He is
called Word only because of things rational λογικά,
vid. Ep. Æg. 13 fin.,
and Wisdom because of things gifted with wisdom, and Power because of
things gifted with power, surely He must be named a Son because of
those who are made sons: and perhaps because there are things existing,
He has even His existence Of
course this line of thought consistently followed, leads to a kind of
Pantheism; for what is the Supreme Being, according to it, but an ideal
standard of perfection, the sum total of all that we see excellent in
the world in the highest degree, a creation of our minds, without real
objective existence? The true view of our Lord’s titles, on the
other hand, is that He is That properly and in perfection, of which in
measure and degree the creatures partake from and in Him. Vid. supr.
de Decr. 17, n. 5., in our notions
only κατ᾽
ἐπίνοιαν, in idea or notion. This is a phrase of very frequent occurrence,
both in Athan. and other writers. We have found it already just above,
and de Syn. 15. Or. i. 9, also Orat. iv. 2, 3.
de Sent. D. 2, Ep. Æg 12, 13, 14. It denotes our
idea or conception of a thing in contrast to the thing itself. Thus,
the sun is to a savage a bright circle in the sky; a man is a
‘rational animal,’ according to a certain process of
abstraction; a herb may be medicine upon one division, food in another;
virtue may be called a mean; and faith is to one man an argumentative
conclusion, to another a moral peculiarity, good or bad. In like
manner, the Almighty is in reality most simple and uncompounded,
without parts, passions, attributes, or properties; yet we speak of Him
as good or holy, or as angry or pleased, denoting some particular
aspect in which our infirmity views, in which also it can view, what is
infinite and incomprehensible. That is, He is κατ᾽
ἐπίνοιαν holy or merciful, being in reality a Unity which is all
mercifulness and also all holiness, not in the way of qualities but as
one indivisible perfection; which is too great for us to conceive as It
is.. And then after all what is He? for He is
none of these Himself, if they are but His names §19.: and He has but a semblance of being, and is
decorated with these names from us.
Rather this is some recklessness of the devil, or worse, if they are
not unwilling that they should truly subsist themselves, but think that
God’s Word is but in name. Is not this portentous, to say that
Wisdom coexists with the Father, yet not to say that this is the
Christ, but that there are many created powers and wisdoms, of which
one is the Lord whom they go on to compare to the caterpillar and
locust? and are they not profligate, who, when they hear us say that
the Word coexists with the Father, forthwith murmur out, ‘Are you
not speaking of two Unoriginates?’ yet in speaking themselves of
‘His Unoriginate Wisdom,’ do not see that they have already
incurred themselves the charge which they so rashly urge against us The
Anomœan in Max. Dial. i. a. urges against the Catholic
that, if the Son exists in the Father, God is compound. Athan. here
retorts that Asterius speaks of Wisdom as a really existing thing in
the Divine Mind. Vid. next note.? Moreover, what folly is there in that
thought of theirs, that the Unoriginate Wisdom coexisting with God is
God Himself! for what coexists does not coexist with itself, but with
some one else, as the Evangelists say of the Lord, that He was together
with His disciples; for He was not together with Himself, but with His
disciples;—unless indeed they would say that God is of a compound
nature, having wisdom a constituent or complement of His Essence,
unoriginate as well as Himself On
this subject vid. Orat. iv. n. 2. Nothing is more remarkable
than the confident tone in which Athan. accuses Arians as here, and
[Marcellus] in Orat. iv. 2. of considering the Divine Nature as
compound, as if the Catholics were in no respect open to such a charge.
Nor are they; though in avoiding it, they are led to enunciate the most
profound and ineffable mystery. Vid. supr. §33, n. 1. The
Father is the One Simple Entire Divine Being, and so is the Son; They
do in no sense share divinity between Them; Each is ὅλος Θεός. This is not ditheism or tritheism, for they are the same God;
nor is it Sabellianism, for They are eternally distinct and substantive
Persons; but it is a depth and height beyond our intellect, how what is
Two in so full a sense can also in so full a sense be One, or how the
Divine Nature does not come under number. vid. notes on Orat.
iii. 27 and 36. Thus, ‘being uncompounded in nature,’ says
Athan. ‘He is Father of One Only Son.’ de Decr. 11.
In truth the distinction into Persons, as Petavius remarks,
‘avails especially towards the unity and simplicity of
God.’ vid. de Deo, ii. 4, 8., which moreover
they pretend to be the framer of the world, that so they may deprive
the Son of the framing of it. For there is nothing they would not
maintain, sooner than hold the truth concerning the Lord.