bishops (some of whom were without sees, wandering about and having no dioceses, others
again had for many years been deposed for serious causes from their metropolises, and with
these were Pelagians and the followers of Celestius, and some of those who were turned out
of Thessaly), he had the presumption to commit a piece of iniquity no man had ever done
before. For all by himself he drew up a paper which he called a deposition, and reviled and
reproached the most holy and reverend Cyril, bishop of Alexandria, and the most reverend
Memnon, bishop of Ephesus, our brother, and fellow-minister, none of us knowing anything
about it, and not even those who were thus reviling knew what was being done, nor for what
reason they had presumed to do this. But ignoring the anger of God for such behaviour,
and unheeding the ecclesiastical canons, and forgetting that they were hastening to destruc-
tion by such a course of action, under the name of an excommunication, they then reviled
the whole Synod. And placing these acts of theirs on the public bulletin boards, they exposed
them to be read by such as chose to do so, having posted them on the outside of the theatres,
that they might make a spectacle of their impiety. But not even was this the limit of their
audacity; but as if they had done something in accordance with the canons, they dared to
bring what they had done to the ears of the most pious and Christ-loving Emperors. Things
being in this condition, the most holy and reverend Cyril, bishop of Alexandria and the
most reverend Memnon bishop of the city of Ephesus, offered some books composed by
themselves and accusing the most reverend Bishop John and those who with him had done
this thing, and conjuring our holy Synod that John and those with him should be summoned
according to the canons, so that they might apologize for their daring acts, and if they had
any complaints to make they might speak and prove them, for in their written deposition,
or rather sheet of abuse, they made this statement as a pretext, “They are Apollinarians, and
239
Arians, and Eunomians, and therefore they have been deposed by us.” When, therefore,
those who had endured their reviling were present, we again necessarily assembled in the
great church, being more than two hundred bishops, and by a first, second, and third call
on two days, we summoned John and his companions to the Synod, in order that they might
examine those who had been reviled, and might make explanations, and tell the causes
which led them to draw up the sentence of deposition; but he273 did not dare to come.
But it was right that he, if he could truly prove the before-mentioned holy men to be
heretics, both should come and prove the truth of that which, accepted as a true and indubit-
able crime, induced the temerarious sentence against them. But being condemned by his
own conscience he did not come. Now what he had planned was this. For he thought that
when that foundation-less and most unjust reviling was done away, the just vote of the
Synod which it cast against the heretic Nestorius would likewise be dissolved. Being justly
vexed, therefore, we determined to inflict according to law the same penalty upon him and
273 Plural in the Greek but singular in the Latin, which the critical editors consider the correct reading.
448
The Letter of the Synod to Pope Celestine.