Since the
above section was written, another possibility has suggested itself to
me. As remarked below, on p. 45, it is possible that Eusebius issued a
second edition of his History in the year 324 or 325, with a
tenth book added, and that he inserted at that time two remarks not
contained in the first edition of the first nine books. It is possible,
therefore to suppose that the references to the Vita Pamphili,
as an already published book, found in H. E. VI. 32 and VII. 32,
may have been added at the same time. Turning to the latter passage we
find our author saying, “It would be no small matter to show what
sort of man he [Pamphilus] was, and whence he came. But we have
described in a separate work devoted to him all the particulars of his
life, and of the school which he established, and the trials which he
endured in many confessions during the persecution, and the crown of
martyrdom with which he was finally honored. But of all who were
there he was the most admirable” (ἀλλ᾽
οὗτος μὲν τῶν
τῇδε
θαυμασιώτατος). The ἀλλὰ, but, seems
very unnatural after the paragraph in regard to the work which Eusebius
had already written. In fact, to give the word its proper adversative
force after what precedes is quite impossible, and it is therefore
commonly rendered (as in the translation of the passage on p. 321,
below) simply “indeed.” If we suppose the passage in regard
to the Biography of Pamphilus to be a later insertion, the use of
the ἀλλὰ becomes quite
explicable. “It would be no small matter to show what sort of man
he was and whence he came. But (this much I can say here) he was
the most admirable of all who were there.” Certainly the
reference at this point to the Vita Pamphili thus has something
of the look of a later insertion. In VI. 32, the reference to that work
might be struck out without in the least impairing the continuity of
thought. Still further, in VIII. 13, where the Vita is
mentioned, although the majority of the mss.
followed by most of the modern editions have the past tense
ἀνεγρ€ψαμεν
“we have written,” three of the best mss. read ἀναγρ€ψομεν
“we shall write.” Might not this confusion
have arisen from the fact that Eusebius, in revising the
History, instead of rewriting this whole passage simply
substituted in the copy which he had before him the word ἀνεγρ€ψαμεν
for the earlier ἀναγρ€ψομεν, and that some copyist, or copyists, finding the earlier
form still legible, preferred that to the substituted form, thinking
the latter to be an insertion by some unauthorized person? If we were
then to suppose that the Vita Pamphili was written after the
first edition of the History, but before the issue of the
complete work in its revised form, we should place its composition
later than the longer recension of the Martyrs, but earlier than
the shorter recension, and thus explain quite simply the lack of any
reference to the Vita in the former. Against the theory stated
in this note might be urged the serious objection that the reference to
the Martyrs of Palestine in VIII. 13 is allowed to remain in the
future tense even in the revised edition of the History, a fact
which of course argues against the change of ἀναγρ€ψομεν
to ἀνεγρ€ψαμεν
in the reference to the Vita in the same
chapter. Indeed, I do not which to be understood as maintaining this
theory, or as considering it more probable than the one stated in the
text. I suggest it simply as an alternative possibility.