MEMORIALS OF TWO SISTERS [1862-67
purely human point of view, leaving the Divine element
entirely out of sight. It was done here under the most
favourable circumstances by a man of extraordinary learn-
ing and genius, with a devout mind, as far as that can be
said of one who believes we can attain no knowledge of
God. And its utter failure, as he thought to explain the
facts of history or the workings of the human mind, would
rouse up many people to such a vivid sense of God's
working in history as they had never gained before. He
spoke with interest of Stanley's writings on the Bible.
One of them, his "Jewish Church," I am just reading, and
certainly that has a wonderful power of making one feel
the reality of those far-off scenes and times, and appreciate
the greatness of the gain to the world in the revelation
through Abraham and Moses.
CATHERINE to A FKIEND
31 CORNWALLIS CRESCENT, CLIFTON,
Feby. 2oth, 1864.
As to your great question, one dare not try to answer
it at all, without saying first how inadequate one feels
one's self to deal with these deep matters thoroughly. All
I can do is just to put before you the considerations which
satisfy my own mind, and leave you to think out for your-
self all that is involved in them. It seems to me that our
certainty as to the ultimate facts of the universe, or funda-
mental propositions of belief, rests on a twofold foundation
our own consciousness, and the external witness to
that consciousness given by the consciousness of the race,
and by the laws of the universe, so far as we know them.
If we had the internal consciousness only, we could never
be sure that it was not a subjective delusion ; if we
had the external testimony only, it might produce belief, like
that of a blind man in colours, but not conviction or know-
ledge ; we could not even rightly understand it. Our con-
sciousness tells us that at any given time we can do one of
two (or more) things, that one of these is higher, better than