His own theory of the origin of
the soul, or at least that to which he visibly inclines, is stated in
the treatise, De Animâ et Resurrectione, p. 241. It is that
of Tertullian and some Greek Fathers also: and goes by the name of
‘traducianism.’ The soul is transmitted in the generating
seed. This of course is the opposite pole to Origen’s teaching,
and is inconsistent with Gregory’s own spiritualism. The other
alternative, Creationism, which a number of the orthodox adopted,
namely that souls are created by God at the moment of conception, or
when the body of the fœtus is already formed, was not open to him
to adopt; because, according to him, in idea the world of spirits was
made, and in a determinate number, along with the world of unformed
matter by the one creative act ‘in the beginning.’ In the
plan of the universe, though not in reality as with Origen, all souls
are already created. So the life of humanity contains them: when the
occasion comes they take their beginning along with the body which
enshrines them, but are not created then any more than that body. Such
was the compromise between spiritualism and materialism to which
Gregory was driven by the difficulties of the subject. Origen with his
eye unfalteringly fixed upon the ideal world, and unconscious of the
practical consequences that might be drawn from his teaching, cut the
knot with his eternal pre-existence of souls, which avoided at once the
alleged absurdity of creationism and the grossness of traducianism. But
the Church, for higher interests still than those of pure idealism, had
to reject that doctrine; and Gregory, with his extended knowledge in
physic and his close observation of the intercommunion of mind and
body, had to devise or rather select a theory which, though a
makeshift, would not contradict either his knowledge or his
faith.