The fault found by the Church with Montanus’ prophecy was
rather because of its form than because of its substance. It was
admitted that the prophecies contained much that was true, but the
soberer sense of the Church at large objected decidedly to the frenzied
ecstasy in which they were delivered. That a change had come over the
Church in this respect since the apostolic age is perfectly clear. In
Paul’s time the speaking with tongues, which involved a similar
kind of ecstasy, was very common; so, too, at the time the
Didache was written the prophets spoke in an ecstasy
(ἐν
πνεύματι, which can mean nothing else; cf. Harnack’s edition, p. 122
sq.). But the early enthusiasm of the Church had largely passed away by
the middle of the second century; and though there were still prophets
(Justin, for instance, and even Clement of Alexandria knew of them),
they were not in general characterized by the same ecstatic and
frenzied utterance that marked their predecessors. To say that there
were none such at this time would be rash; but it is plain that they
had become so decidedly the exception that the revival by the
Montanists of the old method on a large scale and in its extremest form
could appear to the Church at large only a decided innovation. Prophecy
in itself was nothing strange to them, but prophecy in this form they
were not accustomed to, and did not realize that it was but a revival
of the ancient form (cf. the words of our author, who is evidently
quite ignorant of that form). That they should be shocked at it is not
to be wondered at, and that they should, in that age, when all such
manifestations were looked upon as supernatural in their origin, regard
these prophets as under the influence of Satan, is no more surprising.
There was no other alternative in their minds. Either the prophecies
were from God or from Satan; not their content mainly, but the manner
in which they were delivered aroused the suspicion of the bishops and
other leaders of the Church. Add to that the fact that these prophets
claimed supremacy over the constituted Church authorities, claimed that
the Church must be guided by the revelations vouchsafed to women and
apparently half-crazy enthusiasts and fanatics, and it will be seen at
once that there was nothing left for the leaders of the Church but to
condemn the movement, and pronounce its prophecy a fraud and a work of
the Evil One. That all prophecy should, as a consequence, fall into
discredit was natural. Clement (Strom. I. 17) gives the speaking
in an ecstasy as one of the marks of a false prophet,—Montanism
had evidently brought the Church to distinct consciousness on that
point,—while Origen, some decades later, is no longer acquainted
with prophets, and denies that they existed even in the time of Celsus
(see Contra Cels. VII. 11).