Excursus on the Conciliabulum of John of Antioch.
The assembly referred to in this canon is one held by John of Antioch who had delayed
his coming so as to hamper the meeting of the synod. John was a friend of Nestorius and
made many fruitless attempts to induce him to accept the orthodox faith. It will be noticed
that the conciliabulum was absolutely silent with respect to Nestorius and his doctrine and
contented itself with attacking St. Cyril and the orthodox Memnon, the bishop of Ephesus.
St. Cyril and his friends did indeed accuse the Antiochenes of being adherents of Nestorius,
and in a negative way they certainly were so, and were in open opposition to the defenders
of the orthodox faith; but, as Tillemont263 has well pointed out, they did not theologically
agree with the heresy of Nestorius, gladly accepted the orthodox watchword “Mother of
God,” and subsequently agreed to his deposition.
The first session of the Council of Ephesus had already taken place on June 22, and it
was only on June 26th or 27th, that John of Antioch arrived at last at Ephesus.
(Hefele, History of the Councils, Vol. III., p. 55 et seqq.)
The Synod immediately sent a deputation to meet him, consisting of several bishops
and clerics, to show him proper respect, and at the same time to make him acquainted with
the deposition of Nestorius, so that he might not be drawn into any intercourse with him.
The soldiers who surrounded Archbishop John prevented the deputation from speaking to
him in the street; consequently they accompanied him to his abode, but were compelled to
wait here for several hours, exposed to the insults of the soldiers, and at last, when they had
discharged their commission, were driven home, ill-treated and beaten. Count Irenæus,
the friend of Nestorius, had suggested this treatment, and approved of it. The envoys im-
mediately informed the Synod of what had happened, and showed the wounds which they
had received, which called forth great indignation against John of Antioch. According to
the representation of Memnon, excommunication was for this reason pronounced against
him; but we shall see further on that this did not take place until afterwards, and it is clear
that Memnon, in his brief narrative, has passed over an intermediate portion—the threefold
invitation of John. In the meantime, Candidian had gone still further in his opposition to
the members of the synod, causing them to be annoyed and insulted by his soldiers, and
even cutting off their supply of food, while he provided Nestorius with a regular body-guard
of armed peasants. John of Antioch, immediately after his arrival, while still dusty from the
journey, and at the time when he was allowing the envoys of the synod to wait, held at his
town residence a Conciliabulum with his adherents, at which, first of all Count Candidian
related how Cyril and his friends, in spite of all warnings, and in opposition to the imperial
decrees, had held a session five days before, had contested his (the count’s) right to be
present, had dismissed the bishops sent by Nestorius, and had paid no attention to the letters
263 Tillemont, Mémoires, Tom. xiv.
Excursus on the Conciliabulum of John of Antioch.
427
Excursus on the Conciliabulum of John of Antioch.