form to the two disciples, and by His appearing, not as a spirit, but in His true body, to the
disciples in the upper chamber, although the doors were shut.2301
8. From this arises the question as to angels, whether they have bodies adapted to their
duties and their swift motions from place to place, or are only spirits? For if we say that they
have bodies, we are met by the passage: “He maketh His angels spirits;”2302 and if we say
that they have not bodies, a still greater difficulty meets us in explaining how, if they are
without bodily form, it is written that they appeared to the bodily senses of men, accepted
offers of hospitality, permitted their feet to be washed, and used the meat and drink which
was provided for them.2303 For it seems to involve us in less difficulty, if we suppose that
the angels are there called spirits in the same manner as men are called souls, e.g. in the
statement that so many souls (not signifying that they had not bodies also) went down with
Jacob into Egypt,2304 than if we suppose that, without bodily form, all these things were
done by angels. Again, a certain definite height is named in the Apocalypse as the stature
of an angel, in dimensions which could apply only to bodies, proving that that which appeared
to the eyes of men is to be explained, not as an illusion, but as resulting from the power
which we have spoken of as easily put forth by spiritual bodies. But whether angels have
bodies or not, and whether or not any one be able to show how without bodies they could
do all these things, it is nevertheless certain, that in that city of the holy in which those of
our race who have been redeemed by Christ shall be united for ever to thousands of angels,
voices proceeding from organs of speech shall furnish expression to the thoughts of minds
in which nothing is hidden; for in that divine fellowship it will not be possible for any thought
in one to remain concealed from another, but there shall be complete harmony and oneness
of heart in the praise of God, and this shall find utterance not only from the spirit, but
through the spiritual body as its instrument; this, at least, is what I believe.
9. Meanwhile, if you have already found or can learn from other teachers anything more
fully agreeing with the truth than this, I am most eagerly longing to be instructed therein
by you. Study carefully, if you please, my letter, in regard to which, as you pled in excuse
for your very hurried reply the haste of the deacon who brought it to me, I do not make any
complaint, but rather remind you of it, in order that what was then omitted in your answer
may now be supplied. Look over it again, and observe what I wished to learn from you, both
regarding your opinion concerning Christian retirement as a means to the acquisition and
discussion of the truths of Christian wisdom, and regarding that retirement in which I
2301 Luke xxiv. 15–43; John xx. 14–29; Mark xvi. 12, 14.
2302 Ps. civ. 4 and Heb. i. 7.
2303 Gen. xviii. 2–9 and Gen. xix. 1–3.
2304 Gen. xlvi. 27.
887
To Paulinus and Therasia