Proofs that the
Union was without Confusion.
1. Those who believe that after
the union there was one nature both of Godhead and of manhood, destroy
by this reasoning the peculiarities of the natures; and their
destruction involves denial of either nature. For the confusion of the
united natures prevents us from recognising either that flesh is flesh
or that God is God. But if even after the union the difference of the
united natures is clear, it follows that there is no confusion and that
the union is without confusion. And if this is confessed then the
Master Christ is not one nature, but one Son shewing either nature
unimpaired.
2. We too assert the union, and
ourselves confess that it took place at the conception; if then by the
union the natures were mixed and confounded, how was the flesh after
the birth not seen to possess any new quality, but exhibited the human
character, preserved the dimensions of the babe, was wrapped in
swaddling clothes, and sucked a mother’s breast? And if all this
did not come to pass in mere phantasy and seeming, then they admit of
neither phantasy nor seeming; then what was seen was truly a body. And
if this be granted then the natures were not confounded by the union,
but each remained unimpaired.
3. The authors of this patchwork
and incongruous heresy at one time assert that God the Word was made
flesh, and at another declare that the flesh underwent a change into
nature of Godhead. Either statement is futile and vain and full of
falsehood, for if God the Word, as they argue, was made flesh, why then
do they call Him God, and this alone, and refuse to name Him man as
well, and find great fault with us who in addition to confessing Him as
God also call Him man? But if the flesh was changed into the nature of
Godhead, wherefore do they substitute the antitypes of the body? For
the type is superfluous when the reality is destroyed.
4. An incorporeal nature is not
corporeally circumcised, but the word corporeally is added on account
of the spiritual circumcision of the heart; so then the circumcision is
of a body; but the Master Christ is circumcised after the union. And if
this is granted then the argument of the confusion is
confuted.
5. We have learnt that the Saviour Christ hungered and thirsted,
and we have believed that this was so really and not in seeming, but
such conditions belong not to a bodiless nature but to a body. The
Master Christ then had a body which before the resurrection was
affected according to its nature. And to this the divine Apostle bears
testimony when he says “For we have not an High Priest which
cannot be touched with the feeling of our infirmities but was in all
points tempted like as we are yet without sin.”
1585
For the sin is not of the nature but of
the evil will.
1586
6. Of the divine nature the
prophet David says, “Behold He that keepeth Israel shall neither
slumber nor sleep.”
1587
But the
narrative of the Evangelist describes the Master Christ as sleeping in
the boat. Now not sleeping and being asleep are two contrary ideas, so
the prophet contradicts the Gospels if, as they argue, the Master
Christ was God alone. There is no contradiction, for both prophecies
and gospels flow from one and the same spirit. The Master Christ
therefore had a body, akin to all other bodies, affected by the need of
sleep. So the argument for the confusion is proved a fable.
7. Of the divine nature the
prophet Isaiah said, “He shall neither be hungry nor
weary”
1588
and so on. But the Evangelist
says “Jesus being weary with his journey sat thus on the
well;”
1589
and “shall not be
weary” is contrary to “being weary.” Therefore the
prophecy is contrary to the narrative of the gospels. But they are not
contrary, for both are of one God. Not being weary is of the
uncircumscribed nature which fills all things. But moving from place to
place is of the circumscribed nature; and when that which moves is
constrained to travel it is subject to the weariness of the wayfarer.
Therefore what walked and was weary was a body, for the union did not
confound the natures.
8. To the divine Paul when shut
up in prison the Master Christ said “Be not afraid Paul”
1590
and so on. But the same Christ, who drove
away Paul’s fear, Himself so feared, as testifies the blessed
Luke that He sweated from all His body drops of blood, and with them
sprinkled all the ground about His body, and was strengthened by
angelic succour,
1591
and these
statements are opposed to one another, for how can fearing be other
than contrary to driving away fear? Yet they are not contrary. For the
same Christ is by nature God and man; as God He strengthens them that
need consolation; as man He receives consolation through an angel. And
although the Godhead and the Spirit were present as an anointing, the
body and the soul were not then supported either by the Godhead united
to them or by the Holy Ghost, but this service was entrusted to an
angel in order to exhibit the infirmity both of the soul and of the
body and that through the infirmity might be seen the natures of the
infirm. Now these things plainly happened by the permission of the
divine nature, that, among them that were to live in future times,
believers in the assumption of the soul and of the body might be
vindicated by these demonstrations, and their opponents by plain proof
convicted. If then the union was effected by the conception, and, as
they argue, made both natures one, how could the properties of the
natures continue unimpaired, the soul agonize, and the body sweat so as
to sweat bloody drops from excess of fear? But if the one is natural to
the body and the other to the soul, then the union did not effect one
nature of flesh and Godhead, but one Son appeared shewing forth in
Himself both the human and the divine.
9. Should they say that after
the resurrection the body underwent mutation into Godhead they may
properly be answered thus. Even after the resurrection the body was
seen circumscribed with hands and feet and all the body’s parts;
it was tangible and visible; it had wounds and scars, as it had before
the resurrection. One then of two alternatives must be maintained.
Either these parts must be attributed to the divine nature, if the body
when changed into the divine nature had these parts; or on the other
hand it must be confessed that the body remained within the bounds of
its own nature. Now the divine nature is simple and incomposite, but
the body is composite and divided into many parts; therefore it was not
changed into the nature of Godhead, but even after the resurrection
though immortal, incorruptible and full of divine glory, it remains a
body with its own circumscription.
10. To the unbelieving apostles
the Lord after His resurrection shewed His hands, His feet, and the
prints of the nails; then further to teach them that what they saw was
not a vision He added “a spirit hath not flesh and bones as ye
see me have.”
1592
Therefore the body was
not changed into spirit it was flesh and bones and hands and feet.
Consequently even after the resurrection the body remained a
body.
11. The divine nature is
invisible, but the thrice blessed Stephen said that he saw the Lord,
1593
so even after the resurrection the
Lord’s body is a body, and it was seen by the victorious Stephen,
since the divine nature cannot be seen.
12. If all mankind shall see the
Son of man coming on the clouds of heaven, according to the
Lord’s own words,
1594
and He said to
Moses “No man shall see me and live,”
1595
and both are true, then He will come with
the body with which He ascended into heaven. For that body is visible,
and of this the angel spoke to the Apostles “This same Jesus
which is taken up from you into Heaven shall so come in like manner as
ye have seen Him go into Heaven.”
1596
If this is true, as true it is, then there is not one nature of flesh
and Godhead, but the union is without confusion.
1585
Hebrews iv.
15
1586
cf. note on page 164.
1587
Psalm cxxi. 4
1588
Isaiah xl. 28
, lxx.
1589
John iv. 6
1590
When
Paul was brought into the castle the Lord stood by him and said,
“Be of good cheer Paul” (
Acts xxiii.
11
.)
“Fear not Paul” was said when he was being exceedingly
tossed in the tempest (
Acts xxvii.
24
).
1591
Luke xxii. 44
1592
Luke xxiv. 39
1593
Acts vii. 55
1594
Matt. xxvi.
64
1595
Exodus xxxiii.
20
1596
Acts i. 11