SECT. II.
We should judge by the rule of Scripture.
Another foundation-error of those who do not acknowledge the divinity of this work
is, not taking the Holy Scriptures as whole, and in itself a sufficient rule to judge of such
things by. They who have one certain consistent rule to judge by, are like to come to some
clear determination; but they who have a dozen different rules, instead of justly and clearly
determining, do but perplex and darken themselves and others. They who would learn the
true measure of any thing, and will have many different measures to try it by, have a task
that they will not accomplish.—Those of whom I am speaking will indeed make some use
of Scripture, so far as they think it serves their turn, but do not make use of it alone as a rule
sufficient by itself, but make as much and a great deal more use of other things, diverse and
wide from it, by which to judge of this work. For,
1. Some make philosophy, instead of the Holy Scriptures, their rule of judging of this
work; particularly the philosophical notions they entertain of the nature of the soul, its fac-
ulties and affections. Some are ready to say, “There is but little sober solid religion in this
work; it is little else but flash and noise. Religion now all runs out into transports and high
flights of the passions and affections.” In their philosophy, the affections of the soul are
something diverse from the will, and not appertaining to the noblest part of the soul. They
are ranked among the meanest principles that belong to men as partaking of animal nature,
and what he has in common with the brute creation, rather than any thing whereby he is
conformed to angels and pure spirits. And though they acknowledge that a good use may
be made of the affections in religion, yet they suppose that the substantial part of religion
does not consist in them, but that they are something adventitious and accidental in Chris-
tianity.
But these gentlemen, I cannot but think, labour under great mistakes, both in their
philosophy and divinity. It is true; distinction must be made in the affections or passions.
There is a great deal of difference in high and raised affections, which must be distinguished
by the skill of the observer. Some are much more solid than others. There are many exercises
of the affections that are very flashy, and little to be depended on; and oftentimes a great
deal appertains to them, or rather is the effect of them, that has its seat in animal nature,
and is very much owing to the constitution and frame of the body; and that which sometimes
more especially obtains the name of passion, is nothing solid or substantial. But it is false
philosophy to suppose this to be the case with all exercises of affection in the soul, or with
all great and high affections; and false divinity to suppose that religious affections do not
appertain to the substance and essence of Christianity. On the contrary, it seems to me that
the very life and soul of all true religion consists in them.
I humbly conceive that the affections of the soul are not properly distinguished from
the will, as though they were two faculties. All Acts of the affections are in some sense acts
SECTION II. We should judge by Scripture.
1565
SECTION II. We should judge by Scripture.