148
are shown to have been men. There is, as we have said, a similarity between this case and
that of Numa; for the priest being afraid because he had revealed a mystery, earnestly begged
of Alexander to command his mother to burn the letter which conveyed these communica-
tions to her. Let these two theologies, then, the fabulous and the civil, give place to the
Platonic philosophers, who have recognized the true God as the author of all things, the
source of the light of truth, and the bountiful bestower of all blessedness. And not these
only, but to these great acknowledgers of so great a God, those philosophers must yield who,
having their mind enslaved to their body, supposed the principles of all things to be mater-
ial; as Thales, who held that the first principle of all things was water; Anaximenes, that it
was air; the Stoics, that it was fire; Epicurus, who affirmed that it consisted of atoms, that is
to say, of minute corpuscules; and many others whom it is needless to enumerate, but who
believed that bodies, simple or compound, animate or inanimate, but nevertheless bodies,
were the cause and principle of all things. For some of them—as, for instance, the Epicur-
eans—believed that living things could originate from things without life; others held that
all things living or without life spring from a living principle, but that, nevertheless, all
things, being material, spring from a material principle. For the Stoics thought that fire,
that is, one of the four material elements of which this visible world is composed, was both
living and intelligent, the maker of the world and of all things contained in it,—that it was
in fact God. These and others like them have only been able to suppose that which their
hearts enslaved to sense have vainly suggested to them. And yet they have within themselves
something which they could not see: they represented to themselves inwardly things which
they had seen without, even when they were not seeing them, but only thinking of them.
But this representation in thought is no longer a body, but only the similitude of a body;
and that faculty of the mind by which this similitude of a body is seen is neither a body nor
the similitude of a body; and the faculty which judges whether the representation is beautiful
or ugly is without doubt superior to the object judged of. This principle is the understanding
of man, the rational soul; and it is certainly not a body, since that similitude of a body which
it beholds and judges of is itself not a body. The soul is neither earth, nor water, nor air,
nor fire, of which four bodies, called the four elements, we see that this world is composed.
And if the soul is not a body, how should God, its Creator, be a body? Let all those philo-
sophers, then, give place, as we have said, to the Platonists, and those also who have been
ashamed to say that God is a body, but yet have thought that our souls are of the same nature
as God. They have not been staggered by the great changeableness of the soul,—an attribute
which it would be impious to ascribe to the divine nature,—but they say it is the body which
changes the soul, for in itself it is unchangeable. As well might they say, “Flesh is wounded
by some body, for in itself it is invulnerable.” In a word, that which is unchangeable can be
changed by nothing, so that that which can be changed by the body cannot properly be said
to be immutable.
343
That It is Especially with the Platonists that We Must Carry on Our Disputations…