Chapter XXXIII.—The Error of Beryllus.
1. Beryllus,2033 whom we mentioned recently as bishop of Bostra in Arabia, turned aside
from the ecclesiastical standard2034 and attempted to introduce ideas foreign to the faith.
He dared to assert that our Saviour and Lord did not pre-exist in a distinct form of being
of his own2035 before his abode among men, and that he does not possess a divinity of his
own,2036 but only that of the Father dwelling in him.
2. Many bishops carried on investigations and discussions with him on this matter, and
Origen having been invited with the others, went down at first for a conference with him
to ascertain his real opinion. But when he understood his views, and perceived that they
were erroneous, having persuaded him by argument, and convinced him by demonstration,
278
he brought him back to the true doctrine, and restored him to his former sound opinion.
3. There are still extant writings of Beryllus and of the synod held on his account, which
contain the questions put to him by Origen, and the discussions which were carried on in
his parish, as well as all the things done at that time.
2033 Beryllus, bishop of Bostra in Arabia (mentioned above, in chap. 20) is chiefly noted on account of the
heresy into which he fell, and from which Origen won him back, by convincing him of his error. According to
chap. 20, he was a learned and cultured man, and Jerome (de vir. ill. c. 60) says of him, gloriose rexisset ecclesiam.
We do not know his dates, but we may gather from this chapter that the synod which was called on his account
convened during the reign of Gordian (238–244), and apparently toward the close of the reign. Our sources for
a knowledge of the heresy of Beryllus are very meager. We have only the brief passage in this chapter; a fragment
of Origen’s commentary on Titus (Lommatzsch, V. 287), which undoubtedly refers to Beryllus’ error, though
he is not mentioned by name; and finally, a single sentence in Jerome’s de vir. ill. c. 60 (Christum ante incarn-
ationem regat), which, however, is apparently no more than his own interpretation of Eusebius’ words. Our
sources have been interpreted very differently, some holding Beryllus to have been a Patripassian, others classing
him with the Artemonites (see above, Bk. V. chap. 28). He was, at any rate, a Monarchion, and his position, not
to enter here into details, seems to have been that our Lord did not pre-exist as an independent being; but that,
with the incarnation, he, who had previously been identified with the πατρικὴ θεότης, became a distinct being,
possessed of an independent existence (see Dorner’s Person of Christ, Div. I. Vol. II. p. 35 sq., Edinburgh edition).
According to this chapter and chap. 20, Beryllus was the author of numerous treatises and epistles, which were
extant in Eusebius’ time. According to Jerome (l.c.), he wrote, varia opuscula et maxime epistolas, in quibus
Origeni gratias agit. Jerome reports, also, that there were extant in his time epistles of Origen, addressed to
Beryllus, and a dialogue between Origen and Beryllus. All traces of these epistles and other works have perished.
2034 τὸν ἐκκλησιαστικὸν κανόνα: i.e. the rule of faith.
2035 μὴ προϋφεστ€ναι κατ᾽ ἰδίαν οὐσίας περιγραφήν
2036 θεότητα ἰδίαν.
The Error of Beryllus.
695
The Error of Beryllus.