LETTER CXXXIII.
279
shew to have marked patriarchs, prophets, or
apostles. Listen to the Church's words, plain as they may seem to you or crude or ignor-
ant. And speak what you think ; preach
publicly what secretly you tell your disciples.
You profess to have freedom of choice ; why
do you not speak your thoughts freely ?
Your secret chambers hear one doctrine, the
crowd around the platform hear another.
The uneducated throng, I suppose, is not
able to digest your esoteric teaching. Satis-
fied with the milk-diet of an infant it cannot
take solid food.1
I have written nothing yet, and still you
menace me with the thunders of a reply ;
hoping, I suppose, that I may be scared by
your terrors and may not venture to open
my mouth. You fail to see that my purpose
in writing is to force you to answer and to
commit yourself plainly to doctrines which
at present you maintain or ignore, as time,
place, and person require. One kind of
freedom I must deny to you, the freedom to
deny what you have once written. An open
avowal on your part of the opinions that
you hold will be a victory for the church.
For either the language of your reply will
correspond to mine, in which case I shall
count you no longer as opponents but as
friends ; or else you will gainsay my doctrine,
in which case the making known of your
opinion to all the churches will be a triumph
for me. To have brought your tenets to
light is to have overcome them. Blasphemy
is written on the face of them, and a doctrine,
which in its very statement is blasphemous, needs no refutation. You threaten me with
a reply, but this nobody can escape except the man who does not write at all. How do
you know what I am going to say that you
talk of a reply ? Perhaps I shall take your
view and then you will have sharpened your
wits to no purpose. Eunomians, Arians,
Macedonians — all these, unlike in name,
alike in impiety, give me no trouble. For
they say what they think. Yours is the only
heresy which blushes openly to maintain
what secretly it does not fear to teach. But
the frenzy of the disciples exposes the silence
of the masters ; for what they have heard
from them in the closet they preach upon
the housetop. If their auditors like what
they say, their masters get the credit ; and if
they dislike it, only the disciples are blamed,
the masters go free. In this way your heresy
has grown and you have deceived many ;
especially those who cleave to women and
are assured that they cannot sin. You are
always teaching, you are always denying ;
1 cf. i Cor. in. 2.
you deserve to have the prophet's words ap-
plied to you : " give to them glory, O Lord, when they are in travail and in the throes of
labour.' Give them, O Lord ; what wilt thou give ? Give them a miscarrying womb and
dry breasts." ' My temper rises and I can- not check my words. The limits of a letter
do not admit of a lengthy discussion. I as-
sail nobody by name here. It is only against
the teacher of perverse doctrine that I have
spoken. If resentment shall induce him to
reply, he will but betray himself like a mouse
which always leaves traces of its presence ;
and, when it comes to blows in earnest, will receive more serious wounds.
12. From my youth up until now I have
spent many years in writing various works
and have always tried to teach my hearers
the doctrine that I have been taught publicly
in church. I have not followed the philoso-
phers in their discussions but have preferred
to acquiesce in the plain words of the apos- tles. For I have known that it is written :
" I will destroy the wisdom of the wise, and will bring to nothing the understanding of
the prudent,"2 and " the foolishness of God
is wiser than men."' This being the case, I challenge my opponents thoroughly to sift
all my past writings and, if they can find
anything that is faulty in them, to bring it
to light. One of two things must happen.
Either my works will be found edifying and I
shall confutethe false charges brought against
me ; or they will be found blameworthy and
I shall confess my error. For I would
sooner correct an error than persevere in an
opinion proved to be wrong. And as for
you, illustrious doctor, go you and do like- wise : either defend the statements that you
have made, and support your clever theories
with corresponding eloquence, and do not
when the whim takes you disown your own
words ; or if, as a man may do, you have
made a mistake, confess it frankly and re-
store harmony where there has been disagree- ment. Recall to mind how even the soldiers
did not rend the coat of the Saviour." When
you see brothers at strife you laugh ; and
are glad that some are called by your name
and others by that of Christ. Better would it
be to imitate Jonah and say : " If it is for my sake that this great tempest is upon you, take
me up and cast me forth into the sea." ' He in his humility was thrown into the deep that
he might rise again in glory to be a type of
the Lord.' But you are lifted up in your pride to the stars, only that of you too Jesus may
1 Hos. ix. n, 14, partly after the LXX., partly from memory.
3 Isa. xxix. 14, as quoted by Paul, i Cor. i. 19.
» i Cor. i. 35. 4 Job. xix. 23, 24.
« Matt. '
• Jon. i. 12.
xn. 39, 40.