THE PERPETUAL VIRGINITY OF BLESSED MARY. 337
at once answers the question why certain per- sons are called his brethren.
5. This, however, is a point which will find
its proper place further on. We must now
hasten to other matters. The passage for
discussion now is, " And Joseph arose from his sleep, and did as the angel of the Lord
commanded him, and took unto him his wife,
and knew her not till she had brought forth a
son, and he called his name Jesus." Here, first of all, it is quite needless for our oppo-
nent to show so elaborately that the word know
has reference to coition, rather than to intel-
lectual apprehension : as though anyone de-
nied it, or any person in his senses could
ever imagine the .folly which Helvidius takes
pains to refute. Then he would teach us
that the adverb //// implies a fixed and definite
time, and when that is fulfilled, he says the
event takes place which previously did not
take place, as in the case before us, "and knew her not till she had brought forth a
son." It is clear, says he, that she was known after she brought forth, and that that knowl-
edge was only delayed by her engendering a
son. To defend his position he piles up text
upon text, waves his sword like a blind-folded
gladiator, rattles his noisy tongue, and ends
with wounding no one but himself.
6. Our reply is briefly this, — the words knew
and //'// in the language of Holy Scripture are capable of a double meaning. As to the
former, he himself gave us a dissertation to
show that it must be referred to sexual inter-
course, and no one doubts that it is often used
of the knowledge of the understanding, as,
for instance, " the boy Jesus tarried behind in
Jerusalem, and his parents knew it not." Now we have to prove that just as in the one
case he has followed the usage of Scripture,
so with regard to the word //'// he is utterly refuted by the authority of the same Scrip-
ture, which often denotes by its use a fixed
time (he himself told us so), frequently time
without limitation, as when God by the mouth
of the prophet says to certain persons,1 "Even
to old age I am he." Will He cease to be God when they have grown old ? And the Saviour
in the Gospel tells the Apostles,8 "Lo, I am with you alway, even unto the end of the
world." Will the Lord then after the end of the world has come forsake His disciples, and
at the very time when seated on twelve thrones
they are to judge the twelve tribes of Israel will
they be bereft of the company of their Lord ?
Again Paul the Apostle writing to the Corinth-
ians3 says, ''Christ the first-fruits, afterward
they that are Christ's, at his coming. Then cometh the end, when he shall have delivered
up the kingdom to God, even the Father,
1 Is. xlvi. 4. 22 2 S. Matt, xxviii. 20. ' i Cor. xv. 23 sq.
when he shall have put down all rule, and all
authority and power. For he must reign, till
he hath put all enemies under his feet."
Granted that the passage relates to our Lord's human nature, we do not deny that the words
are spoken of Him who endured the cross and
is commanded to sit afterwards on the right
hand. What does he mean then by saying,
" for he must reign, till he hath put all enemies
under his feet " ? Is the Lord to reign only until His enemies begin to be under His feet,
and once they are under His feet will He cease
to reign ? Of course His reign will then com-
mence in its fulness when His enemies begin
to be under His feet. David also in the fourth
Song of Ascents' speaks thus, " Behold, as the eyes of servants look unto the hand of their
master, as the eyes of a maiden unto the hand
of her mistress, so our eyes look unto the
Lord our God, until he have mercy upon us." Will the prophet, then, look unto the Lord
until he obtain mercy, and when mercy is
obtained will he turn his eyes down to the
ground ? although elsewhere he says,2 " Mine eyes fail for thy salvation, and for the word
of thy righteousness." I could accumulate countless instances of this usage, and cover
the verbosity of our assailant with a cloud of
proofs ; I shall, however, add only a few, and
leave the reader to discover like ones for him- self.
7. The word of God says in Genesis,3 "And they gave unto Jacob all the strange gods
which were in their hand, and the rings which
were in their ears ; and Jacob hid them under
the oak which was by Shechem, and lost them
until this day." Likewise at the end of Deu-
teronomy,4 "So Moses the servant of the Lord died there in the land of Moab, according to the word of the Lord. And he buried him in
the valley, in the land of Moab over against
Beth-peor : but no man knoweth of his
sepulchre unto this day." We must certainly understand by this day the time of the compo-
sition of the history, whether you prefer the
view that Moses was the author of the Penta-
teuch or that Ezra re-edited it. In either
case I make no objection. The question now
is whether the words unto this day are to be
referred to the time of publishing or writing
the books, and if so it is for him to show, now
that so many years have rolled away since
that day, that either the idols hidden beneath
the oak have been found, or the grave of
Moses discovered; for he obstinately maintains
that what does not happen so long as the point
of time indicated by until and unto has not
been attained, begins to be when that point
1 Ps. cxxiii. 2. The songs of the up-goin^s or ascents (r^v
dvaftaDiiuiv Sept., graduum K«/[p.i, are the fifteen psalms cxx.- cxxxiv.
2 Ps. cxix. 123. 3 Gen. xxxv. 4, Sept. * Deut. xxxiv. 5-^