II.
(Donation of Constantine, p. 607.)
On this stupendous fraud I quote from Dupin, as
follows:—
“Among the number of Constantine’s edicts I
do not place the Donation which goes under his name. Some have
attributed this false monument to the author of the collection
(Decretals) ascribed to Isidore, he being a notorious forger of such
kind of writings; and this conjecture is more probable than some
others.
“By this Donation, Constantine is supposed to give
to the Bishops of Rome the sovereignty of the city, and of the
provinces of the Western Empire. I note some of the reasons which
clearly prove this instrument to be a forgery:—
“(1) Not one of the ancients mentions this
pretended liberality of the emperor. How could Eusebius, and all
the other historians who wrote about Constantine, have passed over in
silence, had it been a reality, the gift of a Western Empire to the
Bishop of Rome?
“(2) Not one of the Bishops of Rome ever
refers to such a donation, though it would have been much to their
advantage so to do.
“(3) It is dated falsely, and under consuls
who flourished when Constantine was unbaptized; yet his baptism is
referred to in this instrument. Again, the city of Constantinople
is mentioned in it, although it was called Byzantium for ten years
subsequent to its date.
“(4) Not only is the style very different
from the genuine edicts of the emperor, but it is full of terms and
phrases that came into use much after the time of Constantine.
“(5) How comes it that he should have given
one-half of his empire to the Bishop of Rome, including the city of
Rome itself, without any one ever hearing of it for hundreds of years
after?
“(6) The falsities and absurdities of this
edict demonstrate that it was composed by an ignorant impostor.
Thus by it, for example, the Pope is permitted to wear a crown of gold,
and a fabulous history is given of the emperor’s baptism by
Sylvester: also, it contains a history of the emperor’s
miraculous cure of leprosy by Sylvester, all which do plainly prove the
forgery. It is certain that the city of Rome was governed by the
emperor, and that the Bishops of Rome were subject to him, and obeyed
him, as all his other subjects.
“All that we have said plainly shows that
the edict of Donation that bears the name of Constantine is wholly
supposititious; but it is not so easy to find out who was the
author. However it be, this document has neither any use nor
authority.”
2887
2887
Dupin,
ut supra
, p. 17. See also Bryce’s
Holy Roman
Empire
, pp. 43 and 100. He pronounces “the Donation of
Constantine” to be “the
most stupendous
of all the
mediæval forgeries. The Decretals certainly surpass it in
their nature and their effects; but Mr. Bryce’s reference to
these is very feeble and unsatisfactory, after Dupin. See p. 156
of his work, ed. Macmillan, 1880.