3. Dearly beloved brethren, we might have put
forth a defence of our brother Athanasius as respects the conspiracy of
Eusebius and his fellows against him, and complained of his sufferings
at their hands, and have exposed all their false charges, either at the
beginning of their conspiracy or upon his arrival at Alexandria. But
circumstances did not permit it then, as you also know; and lately,
after the return of the Bishop Athanasius, we thought that they would
be confounded and covered with shame at their manifest injustice: in
consequence we prevailed with ourselves to remain silent. Since,
however, after all his severe sufferings, after his retirement into
Gaul, after his sojourn in a foreign and far distant country in the
place of his own, after his narrow escape from death through their
calumnies, but thanks to the clemency of the Emperor,—distress
which would have satisfied even the most cruel enemy,—they are
still insensible to shame, are again acting insolently against the
Church and Athanasius; and from indignation at his deliverance venture
on still more atrocious schemes against him, and are ready with an
accusation, fearless of the words in holy Scripture Prov. xix. 5; Wisd. i.
11.,
‘A false witness shall not be unpunished;’ and, ‘The
mouth that belieth slayeth the soul;’ we therefore are unable
longer to hold our peace, being amazed at their wickedness and at the
insatiable love of contention displayed in their intrigues.