435
Excursus as to Whether the Sardican Council Was Ecumenical.
Some theologians and canonists have been of opinion that the Council of Sardica was
Ecumenical and would reckon it as the Second. But besides the fact that such a numbering
is absolutely in contrariety to all history it also labours under the difficulty, as we shall see
presently, that the Westerns by insisting that St. Athanasius should have a seat caused a di-
vision of the synod at the very outset, so that the Easterns met at Philippopolis and confirmed
the deposition of the Saint. It is also interesting to remember that when Alexander Natalis
in his history expressly called this synod ecumenical, the passage was marked with disap-
proval by the Roman censors.
(Hefele. Hist. Councils. Vol. II., pp. 172 et seqq.)
The ecumenical character of this Synod certainly cannot be proved.411 It is indeed true
that it was the design of Pope Julius, as well as of the two Emperors, Constantius and Con-
stans, to summon a General Council at Sardica; but we do not find that any such actually
took place: and the history of the Church points to many like cases, where a synod was
probably intended to be ecumenical, and yet did not attain that character. In the present
case, the Eastern and Western bishops were indeed summoned, but by far the greater
number of the Eastern bishops were Eusebians, and therefore Semi-Arians, and instead of
acting in a better mind in union with the orthodox, they separated themselves and formed
a cabal of their own at Philippopolis.
We cannot indeed agree with those who maintain that the departure of the Eusebians
in itself rendered it impossible for the synod to be ecumenical, or it would be in the power
of heretics to make an Ecumenical Council possible or not. We cannot, however, overlook
the fact that, in consequence of this withdrawal, the great Eastern Church was far more
poorly represented at Sardica, and that the entire number of bishops present did not even
amount to a hundred! So small a number of bishops can only form a General Council if
the great body of their absent colleagues subsequently give their express consent to what
has been decided. This was not, however, the case at the Synod of Sardica. The decrees
were no doubt at once sent for acceptance and signature to the whole of Christendom, but
not more than about two hundred of those bishops who had been absent signed, and of
these, ninety-four, or nearly half, were Egyptians. Out of the whole of Asia only a few
bishops from the provinces of Cyprus and Palestine signed, not one from the other Eastern
provinces; and even from the Latin Church in Africa, which at that time numbered at least
three hundred bishops, we meet with very few names. We cannot give much weight to the
fact that the Emperor Constantius refused to acknowledge the decrees of Sardica: it is of
much greater importance that no single later authority declared it to be a General Council.
411 Hefele refers to his having himself treated this matter fully in the Theologischer Quartalschriftof Tübingen,
1852.
Excursus as to Whether the Sardican Council Was Ecumenical.
800
Excursus as to Whether the Sardican Council Was Ecumenical.