On Bk. VIII. chap. 2, § 4 (note 3, continued). The Causes of the Diocletian Persecution.
The persecution of Diocletian, following as it did a period of more than forty years
during which Christianity had been recognized as a religio licita, and undertaken as it was
by a man who throughout the first eighteen years of his reign had shown himself friendly
to the Christians, and had even filled his own palace with Christian servants, presents a very
difficult problem to the historian. Why did Diocletian persecute? The question has taxed
the ingenuity of many scholars and has received a great variety of answers. Hunziker (in his
Regierung und Christenverfolgung des Kaisers Diocletianus und seiner Nachfolger, Leipzig,
1869), Burckhardt (in his Zeit Constantins, Basel, 1853, 2d and improved edition, Leipzig,
1880), and A. J. Mason (in his Persecution of Diocletian, Cambridge and London, 1876), not
398
to mention other investigators, have treated the subject with great ability and at considerable
length, and the student is referred to their works for a fuller examination of the questions
involved. It is not my purpose here to discuss the various views that have been presented
by others; but inasmuch as I am unable fully to agree with any of them, I desire to indicate
my own conception of the causes that led to the persecution. We are left almost wholly to
conjecture in the matter; for our only authority, Lactantius, makes so many palpably erro-
neous statements in his description of the causes which produced the great catastrophe that
little reliance can be placed upon him (see Burckhardt’s demonstration of these errors, ibid.
p. 289 sq.). Nevertheless, he has preserved for us at least one fact of deep significance, and
it is a great merit of Mason’s discussion that he has proved so conclusively the correctness
of the report. The fact I refer to is that the initiative came from Galerius, not from Diocletian
himself. Lactantius states this very distinctly and repeatedly, but it has been argued by
Hunziker and many others that the persecution had been in Diocletian’s mind for a long
time, and that it was but the culmination of his entire policy. Having settled political matters,
it is said, he turned his attention to religious matters, and determined as a step toward the
restoration of the old Roman religion in its purity to exterminate Christianity. But, as Mason
shows, this is an entire misconception of Diocletian’s policy. It had never been his intention
to attack Christianity. Such an attack was opposed to all his principles, and was at length
made only under the pressure of strong external reasons. But though Mason has brought
out this important fact so clearly, and though he has shown that Galerius was the original
mover in the matter, he has, in my opinion, gone quite astray in his explanation of the causes
which led Diocletian to accede to the wishes of Galerius. According to Mason, Diocletian
was induced against his will to undertake a course of action which his judgment told him
was unwise. “But the Cæsar [Galerius] was the younger and the stronger man; and a determ-
ination to do has always an advantage over the determination not to do. At length Diocletian
broke down so far as to offer to forbid the profession of the faith within the walls of his
palace and under the eagles of his legions. He was sure it was a mistaken policy. It was cer-
tainly distasteful to himself. The army would suffer greatly by the loss. Diocletian would
On Bk. VIII. chap. 2, § 4 (note 3, continued). The Causes of the Diocletian Persecution.
1019
On Bk. VIII. chap. 2, § 4 (note 3, continued). The Causes of the Diocletian…