All these objections were made and felt bona
fide, although Arians would of course make the most of them. The
subsequent history will show that their force was outweighed only for
the moment with many of the fathers, and that to reconcile the
‘conservatism’ of the Asiatic bishops to the new formula
must be a matter of time. The third or Scriptural objection need not
now be discussed at length. Precedent could be pleaded for the
introduction into creeds of words not expressly found in Scripture
(e.g. the word ‘catholic’ applied to the Church in many
ancient creeds, the creed of Gregory Thaumaturgus with
τρίας τελεία,
&c. &c.); the only question was, were the non-scriptural words
expressive of a Scriptural idea? This was the pith of the
question debated between Athanasius and his opponents for a generation
after the council; the ‘conservative’ majority eventually
came round to the conviction that Athanasius was right. But the
question depends upon the meaning of the word itself.