is the sinfulness of that act; is hard to be conceived. Mr. Edwards rejects, with abhorrence,
the idea that God either is, or can be, the agent, or actor, of sin. He illustrates and explains
this difficult subject, by showing that God may dispose things in such a manner, that sin
will certainly take place in consequence of such a disposal. In maintaining this, he only ad-
heres to his own important doctrine of moral necessity. The divine disposal, by which sin
certainly comes into existence, is only establishing a certainty of its future existence. If that
certainty, which is no other than moral necessity, be not inconsistent with human liberty;
then surely the cause of that certainty, which is no other than the divine disposal, cannot be
inconsistent with such liberty.
“5. The followers of Mr. Edwards have thrown new and important light upon ‘The
Doctrine of Atonement. It has been commonly represented, that the atonement, which Christ
made, was the payment of a debt, due from his people. By this payment, they were purchased
from slavery and condemnation. Hence arose this question,—If the sinner’s debt be paid,
how does it appear that there is any pardon or grace in his deliverance?—The followers of
Mr. Edwards have proved, that the atonement does not consist in the payment of a debt,
properly so called. It consists rather in doing that, which, for the purpose of establishing
the authority of the divine law, and of supporting in due time the divine government, is
equivalent to the punishment of the sinner according to the letter of the law. Now, therefore,
God, without the prostration of his authority and government, can pardon and save those
who believe. As what was done to support the divine government, was not done by the sinner,
so it does not at all diminish the free grace of his pardon and salvation. 91
“6. With respect to The Imputation of Adam’s Sin, and The Imputation of Christ’s
Righteousness, their statements also have been more accurate. The common doctrine had
been, that Adam’s sin is so transferred to his posterity, that it properly becomes their sin.
The righteousness of Christ, likewise, is so transferred or made over to the believer, that it
properly becomes his righteousness. To the believer it is reckoned in the divine account.—On
this the question arises, How can the righteousness or good conduct of one person be the
righteousness or good conduct of another? If, in truth, it cannot be the conduct of that
other; how can God, who is omniscient, and cannot mistake, reckon, judge, or think it to
be the conduct of that other?—The followers of Mr. Edwards find relief from this difficulty,
by proving that to impute righteousness, is, in the language of Scripture, to justify; and that,
to impute the righteousness of Christ, is to justify on account of Christ’s righteousness. The
imputation of righteousness can, therefore, be no transfer of righteousness. They are the
beneficial consequences of righteousness, which are transferred. Not therefore the righteousness
91 It is proper to remark, that the above statement is not altogether correct. The same views of the atonement
appear in Bates on the Harmony of the Divine Attributes in Redemption; in the writings of Howe, Baxter, and
some other eminent divines of the seventeenth century.
410
CHAPTER XXV. Concluding remarks