5. A number of scattered passages in Athanasius
lead us to the same conclusion. For instance, if the Arian formula had
the sense which is here maintained, of being an argument against our
Lord’s eternity, the Catholic answer would be, ‘He could
not be before His generation because His generation is
eternal, as being from the Father.’ Now this is precisely
the language Athanasius uses, when it occurs to him to introduce the
words in question. Thus in Orat. ii. §57 he says,
‘The creatures began to come to be (γίνεσθαι); but the
Word of God, not having beginning (ἀρχὴν) of being, surely did not
begin to be, nor begin to come to be, but was always. And the works
have a beginning (ἀρχὴν) in the making, and the beginning
precedes things which come to be; but the Word not being of such,
rather Himself becomes the Framer of those things which have a
beginning. And the being of things originate is measured by their
becoming (ἐν
τῷ
γίνεσθαι), and at some
beginning (origin) doth God begin to make them through the Word, that
it may be known that they were not before their origination (πρίν
γενέσθαι); but the Word
hath His being in no other origin than the Father (vid. supr. §11,
note 1), ‘whom they themselves allow to be unoriginate, so that
He too exists unoriginately in the Father, being His offspring not His
creature.’ We shall find that other Fathers say just the same.
Again, we have already come to a passage where for ‘His
generation,’ he substitutes ‘making,’ a word which
Bull would not say that either the Nicene Council or S. Hippolytus
would use; clearly shewing that the Arians were not quoting and denying
a Catholic statement in the οὐκ
ἦν πρὶν, &c., but laying
down one of their own. ‘Who is there in all mankind, Greek or
Barbarian, who ventures to rank among creatures One whom he confesses
the while to be God, and says that “He was not ‘before He
was made,’ πρὶν
ποιηθῇ.”’
Orat. i. §10. Arius, who is surely the best explainer of
his own words, says the same; that is, he interprets
‘generation’ by ‘making,’ or confesses that he
is bringing forward an argument, not opposing a dogma; ‘Before
His generation,’ he says, ‘or creation, or
destination (ὁρισθῇ), Rom. i. 4), or founding (vid. Prov. viii. 23), He was not; for He was not
ingenerate.’ Theod., Hist. i. 4. Eusebius of Nicomedia
also, in a passage which has already come before us, says distinctly,
‘“It is plain to any one,” that what has been made
was not before its generation; but what came to be has an origin
of being.’ De Syn. §17.